The Ethics of Immigration
Author:
- 1 September 2005
- journal article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Political Studies Review
- Vol. 3 (3) , 317-334
Abstract
This review essay examines recent work in political theory on the ethics of immigration admissions. It considers arguments put forward by Michael Walzer, Peter Meilaender and David Miller, among others, for state control of borders. Such arguments tend to appeal to the value of political communities and/or the exclusion rights of democratic associations, and I argue that neither of these are successful. Turning to work by Joseph Carens, Phillip Cole, Michael Dummett and others who advocate open or much more open borders, the article considers various arguments that would support this stance, including appeals to freedom of movement, utilitarianism and social justice. I argue that rights to immigration need embedding in global principles of resource redistribution. In the conclusion I sketch a cosmopolitan approach to immigration by which impartial criteria such as population density and gross domestic product would determine how many migrants states have a duty to admit.Keywords
This publication has 40 references indexed in Scilit:
- The Economic Impact of Labour MigrationThe Political Quarterly, 2003
- National Solidarity, Global Impartiality, and the Performance of Philosophical Theory. The Example of Migration PolicyRatio Juris, 1998
- Migration - A Challenge to Modern CitizenshipConstellations, 1998
- Freedom of Association and the Right to ExcludeJournal of Political Philosophy, 1997
- Immigration, justice, and culture1995
- Immigration, identity, and justice1995
- Citizenship, the demands of justice, and the moral relevance of political borders1995
- Admission to CitizenshipEthics, 1988
- The Ethics of Immigration RestrictionSocial Theory and Practice, 1984
- Immigration from Developing Countries: Some Philosophical IssuesEthics, 1983