A step further towards scientific arguments for expert witnesses in the defense of patients accused of forensic parasomnias
Author:
Open Access
- 21 June 2024
- journal article
- editorial
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in SLEEP
- Vol. 47 (8)
Abstract
Whoever sat in court to defend a patient accused for sexual assault or violence during sleep knows about the paucity of objective and scientific arguments for a sleep expert witness that often stands against the conviction of legal and public morals. The article by Peretti et al. [ 1] provides new important arguments that help the expert witness to clarify if the assaults under accusation are caused by a disorder of arousal (DOA) with or without sexsomnia or if the latter is pretended. Apart from these arguments, public opinion needs to get a different view on this deviant behavior, which is not intentional, but occurs in a state of blurred/lack of awareness/consciousness due to a dissociated state between wake and sleep. The judges and the jury must understand and be convinced that an underlying sleep disorder may be the cause. The task of sleep experts is to prove the sleep disorder with strong scientific arguments.Keywords
This publication has 6 references indexed in Scilit:
- Latency to N3 interruption in arousal disordersSLEEP, 2024
- Forensic Evaluation of a Single Episode of a Disorder of Arousal in a Sleepwalking Defense: Cognitive Function Versus Prior Clinical HistorySleep Science, 2023
- Disorders of Arousal and timing of the first period of slow wave sleep: Clinical and forensic implicationsSleep Medicine: X, 2022
- Diagnostic criteria for disorders of arousal: A video‐polysomnographic assessmentAnnals of Neurology, 2018
- Sleep architecture, slow wave activity, and sleep spindles in adult patients with sleepwalking and sleep terrorsClinical Neurophysiology, 2000
- Diagnostic Values of Polysomnography in Forensic MedicineJournal of Forensic Sciences, 2000