From Prediction to Practice: A Systematic Review of the Decision Support Gap in Artificial Intelligence and Machine Learning for Environmentally Sustainable Livestock Production
Open Access
Abstract
Artificial intelligence (AI) and machine learning (ML) are promoted as tools for improving the environmental sustainability of livestock production, but it remains unknown whether the models reported in this literature are used to support real-world decisions. We systematically reviewed studies that applied AI or ML to environmental sustainability outcomes in livestock production. Four databases were searched in January 2026, and 165 of 1994 screened records were included. The protocol was registered, but the main outcome was defined after data extraction, so the analysis is exploratory. A study counted as delivering decision support only if it named a specific decision and used its model to compare options or recommend an action. The authors of 96 studies (58.2%) stated that their work could support decisions, but only 26 studies (15.8%) met our definition. This gap appeared in 10 of 11 application areas. The gap held under both a broader and a stricter definition, and when a second coder repeated the coding. Only 30 studies (18.2%) tested their model outside the setting where it was developed, and 17 (10.3%) included an optimization step, which turns a prediction into a choice. Linking ML with mechanistic farm models is a promising approach that still needs testing. We also describe the main components a practical decision tool would need.Keywords
Funding Information
- U.S. Department of Agriculture (2024-68012-41749)
This publication has 202 references indexed in Scilit:
- Climate change impacts livestock carrying capacity in East AfricaRegional Environmental Change, 2025
- Improving Accuracy of Gridded Livestock Mapping by Combining Trend Modeling and Residual AssignmentLand Degradation & Development, 2024
- Predicting spatiotemporal patterns of productivity and grazing from multispectral data using neural network analysis based on system complexityAgrosystems, Geosciences & Environment, 2024
- Future prediction of biogas potential and CH4 emission with boosting algorithms: the case of cattle, small ruminant, and poultry manure from TurkeyEnvironmental Science and Pollution Research, 2024
- Understanding farmers’ engagement and barriers to machine learning‐based intelligent agricultural decision support systemsAgronomy Journal, 2023
- Modeling of energy and emissions from animal manure using machine learning methods: the case of the Western Mediterranean Region, TurkeyEnvironmental Science and Pollution Research, 2022
- Appraisal of methane production and anaerobic fermentation kinetics of livestock manures using artificial neural networks and sinusoidal growth functionsJournal of Material Cycles and Waste Management, 2020
- Effluent composition prediction of a two-stage anaerobic digestion process: machine learning and stoichiometry techniquesEnvironmental Science and Pollution Research, 2018
- ggplot22016
- A Global Assessment of the Water Footprint of Farm Animal ProductsEcosystems, 2012