Ecological and economic implications of alternative metrics in biodiversity offset markets
Open Access
- 13 June 2022
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Conservation Biology
- Vol. 36 (5)
Abstract
Policy tools are needed that allow reconciliation of human development pressures with conservation priorities. Biodiversity offsetting can be used to compensate for ecological losses caused by development activities. Landowners can choose to undertake conservation actions, including habitat restoration, to generate biodiversity offsets. Consideration of the incentives facing landowners as potential biodiversity offset providers and developers as potential buyers of credits is critical when considering the ecological and economic landscape‐scale outcomes of alternative offset metrics. There is an expectation that landowners will always seek to conserve the least profitable land parcels, and, in turn, this determines the spatial location of biodiversity offset credits. We developed an ecological‐economic model to compare the ecological and economic outcomes of offsetting for a habitat‐based metric and a species‐based metric. We were interested in whether these metrics would adequately capture the indirect benefits of offsetting on species not considered under a no‐net‐loss policy. We simulated a biodiversity offset market for a case study landscape, linking species distribution modeling and an economic model of landowner choice based on economic returns of the alternative land management options (restore, develop, or maintain existing land use). Neither the habitat nor species metric adequately captured the indirect benefits of offsetting on related habitats or species. The underlying species distributions, layered with the agricultural and development rental values of parcels, resulted in very different landscape outcomes depending on the metric chosen. If policy makers are aiming for the metric to act as an indicator to mitigate impacts on a range of closely related habitats and species, then a simple no‐net‐loss target is not adequate. Furthermore, to achieve the most ecologically beneficial design of offsets policy, an understanding of the economic decision‐making processes of the landowners is needed.Keywords
This publication has 23 references indexed in Scilit:
- A Global Mitigation Hierarchy for Nature ConservationBioScience, 2018
- A disaggregated biodiversity offset accounting model to improve estimation of ecological equivalency and no net lossBiological Conservation, 2016
- The transition from No Net Loss to a Net Gain of biodiversity is far from trivialOryx, 2015
- Modeling distribution and abundance of multiple species: Different pooling strategies produce similar resultsEcosphere, 2014
- Comparing biodiversity offset calculation methods with a case study in UzbekistanBiological Conservation, 2014
- No net loss of biodiversity or paper offsets? A critical review of the French no net loss policyEnvironmental Science & Policy, 2014
- Biodiversity offsets in theory and practiceOryx, 2013
- Is restoring flora the same as restoring fauna? Lessons learned from koalas and mining rehabilitationJournal of Applied Ecology, 2013
- Faustian bargains? Restoration realities in the context of biodiversity offset policiesBiological Conservation, 2012
- The cost of policy simplification in conservation incentive programsEcology Letters, 2012