Formal and informal decision making on water management at the village level: A case study from the Office du Niger irrigation scheme (Mali)
- 23 June 2007
- journal article
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in Water Resources Research
- Vol. 43 (6)
Abstract
Water Users Associations (WUAs) are all too often considered a panacea for improving water management in irrigation schemes. Where grassroots movements are absent, they are usually imposed on farmers by national governments, NGOs, and international donors, without fully considering existing forms of organization. This also happened in the Office du Niger irrigation scheme in Mali, where after a partial irrigation management transfer, WUAs were created to fill the resulting power vacuum. This paper demonstrates that, despite active efforts to organize farmers in WUAs, informal patterns of decision making remain dominant. Given the shortcomings of these informal patterns, WUAs could provide a much‐needed platform for institutionalizing collective action, on the condition that farmers accept them. Therefore WUAs should adopt some crucial characteristics of informal patterns of decision making while avoiding their weaknesses. First, making use of the existing authority of village leadership and the central management can improve the credibility of WUAs. Second, allowing flexibility in procedures and rules can make them more appropriate for dealing with collective action problems that are typically temporary and specific. Last, formalizing the current pattern of conflict management and sanctioning might enhance its sphere of action and tackle the current absence of firm engagement with respect to some informal management decisions. In addition, WUAs should represent and be accountable to all farmers, including those residing outside the village community.Keywords
This publication has 26 references indexed in Scilit:
- Reviving Pre‐Socialist Cooperative Traditions: The Case of Water Syndicates in BulgariaSociologia Ruralis, 2005
- Participatory management: Would it be a turning point in the history of the Gezira scheme?Irrigation and Drainage, 2004
- DESTINED TO FAIL: FORCED SETTLEMENT AT THE OFFICE DU NIGER, 1926–45The Journal of African History, 2001
- DISJUNCTURES IN THEORY AND PRACTICE: MAKING SENSE OF CHANGE IN AGRICULTURAL DEVELOPMENT AT THE OFFICE DU NIGER, 1920–60The Journal of African History, 2000
- Collective Action in Common-Pool Resource Management : The Contribution of a Social Constructivist Perspective to Existing TheorySociety & Natural Resources, 1999
- Colonial and Contemporary Ideologies of ‘Community Management’: The Case of Tank Irrigation Development in South IndiaModern Asian Studies, 1999
- Indigenous Irrigation, Agriculture and Development, Marakwet, KenyaThe Geographical Journal, 1998
- Indigenous community-managed irrigation in Sahelian West AfricaAgriculture, Ecosystems & Environment, 1997
- Indigenous Farmer-Managed Irrigation in Sonjo, TanzaniaThe Geographical Journal, 1994
- Design principles in long‐enduring irrigation institutionsWater Resources Research, 1993