Digital Devices for Assessing Motor Functions in Mobility Impaired and Healthy Populations: A Systematic Literature Review (Preprint)
Authors:
- Christine C. GuoCGChristine C. Guo
- Patrizia Andrea ChiesaPCPatrizia Andrea Chiesa
- Carl de MoorCMCarl de Moor
- Mir Sohail FazeliMFMir Sohail Fazeli
- Thomas SchofieldTSThomas Schofield
- Kimberly HoferKHKimberly Hofer
- Shibeshih BelachewSBShibeshih Belachew
- Alf ScotlandASAlf Scotland
Preprint
- 3 March 2022
- preprint
- Published by JMIR Publications Inc. in JMIR Preprints
Abstract
BACKGROUND With the advent of smart sensing technology, mobile and wearable devices can provide continuous and objective monitoring and assessment of motor function outcomes. OBJECTIVE We aimed to describe the existing scientific literature on wearable and mobile technologies that are being used or tested for assessing motor functions in mobility-impaired and healthy adults, and to evaluate the degree to which these devices provide clinically valid measures of motor function in these populations. METHODS A systematic literature review was conducted by searching Embase, MEDLINE®, CENTRAL (January 1, 2015 – June 24, 2020), the United States and European Union clinical trial registries, and the United States Food and Drug Administration website using predefined study selection criteria. Study selection, data extraction, and quality assessment were performed by two independent reviewers. RESULTS Ninety-one publications representing 87 unique studies were included. The most represented clinical conditions were Parkinson’s disease (k = 51 studies), followed by stroke (k = 5), Huntington’s disease (k = 5), and multiple sclerosis (k = 2). A total of 42 motion-detecting devices were identified, and the majority (k = 27; 64%) were created for the purpose of healthcare-related data collection, though approximately 25% were personal electronic devices (e.g., smartphones, watches) and 11% were entertainment consoles (e.g., Microsoft Kinect/Xbox™, Nintendo Wii™). The primary motion outcomes were related to gait (k = 30), gross motor movements (k = 25), and fine motor movements (k = 23). As a group, sensor-derived motion data showed a mean sensitivity of .83 (SD = 7.27), mean specificity of .84 (SD = 15.40), mean accuracy of .90 (SD = 5.87) in discriminating between diseased individuals and healthy controls, and mean Pearson’s r validity coefficient of .52 (SD = 0.22) relative to clinical measures. We did not find significant differences in the degree of validity between in-lab and at-home sensor-based assessments, nor between device class (i.e., healthcare-related device, personal electronic devices, entertainment consoles). CONCLUSIONS Sensor-derived motion data can be leveraged to classify and quantify disease status for a variety of neurological conditions. However, most of recent research on digital clinical measures is derived from proof-of-concept studies with considerable variation in methodological approaches, and much of the reviewed literature has focused on clinical validation, with less than a quarter of the studies performing analytical validation. Overall, future research is crucially needed to further consolidate that sensor-derived motion data may lead to the development of robust and transformative digital measurements intended to predict, diagnose, and quantify neurological disease state and its longitudinal change.Keywords
This publication has 119 references indexed in Scilit:
- Wearable motion sensors to continuously measure real-world physical activitiesCurrent Opinion in Neurology, 2013
- Reliability and Responsiveness of the Gross Motor Function Measure-88 in Children With Cerebral PalsyPhysical Therapy, 2013
- Expanded and independent validation of the Movement Disorder Society–Unified Parkinson’s Disease Rating Scale (MDS-UPDRS)Journal of Neurology, 2012
- Five Years of GWAS DiscoveryThe American Journal of Human Genetics, 2012
- The Cochrane Collaboration's tool for assessing risk of bias in randomised trialsBMJ, 2011
- The assessment of function: How is it measured? A clinical perspectiveJournal of Manual & Manipulative Therapy, 2011
- Voodoo Correlations Are Everywhere—Not Only in NeurosciencePerspectives on Psychological Science, 2011
- Puzzlingly High Correlations in fMRI Studies of Emotion, Personality, and Social CognitionPerspectives on Psychological Science, 2009
- Validity of performance scales for disability assessment in multiple sclerosisMultiple Sclerosis Journal, 2007
- Frequency Distribution of the Values of the Correlation Coefficient in Samples from an Indefinitely Large PopulationBiometrika, 1915