Research organisation responses to the systems transformation agenda: mapping the diversity, potential and limits in an era of uncertainty
Authors:
- Costanza ContiCCCostanza Conti
- Andrew HallAHAndrew Hall
- Enayat A. MoallemiEMEnayat A. Moallemi
- Paola Abril Campos RiveraPRPaola Abril Campos Rivera
- Shibani GhoshSGShibani Ghosh
- Amanda JonssonAJAmanda Jonsson
- Minna KaljonenMKMinna Kaljonen
- Stefan KaufmanSKStefan Kaufman
- Laurens KlerkxLKLaurens Klerkx
- Myrtille LacosteMLMyrtille Lacoste
- Amar LailaALAmar Laila
- Derk LoorbachDLDerk Loorbach
Preprint
- 15 September 2026
- preprint
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Abstract
Research organisations are increasingly expected to generate and mobilise knowledge to address this century’s interlinked environmental, social and economic crises and to help deliver sustainability transformations across the globe. Responding to these expectations, many research organisations are rethinking their agendas, capabilities and organisational arrangements around an explicit transformation mandate. Yet, the conditions required to organise and sustain this work remains ambiguous. To better understand this ongoing shift, we introduce the terminology of Transformation-Oriented Research Organisations (TOROs) - organisations, or identifiable units within them, which core research mandate, explicitly addresses systemic transformation challenges and uses systems-oriented approaches. TOROs share four recurrent orientations: system-level framing; inter- and transdisciplinarity and plural knowledge; explicit directionality and value intermediation; and agility, learning and long-term orientation. Combining a thematic overview of the literature, an expert survey, purposive web-based mapping and semi-structured interviews, we build a typology of TOROs: university-linked; autonomous and social-impact driven; network and platform configurations; and embedded in technology-oriented agencies. Across these types, different benefits, trade-offs and risks are identified, along with four tensions that affect continuity and credibility: demonstrating their contribution to long-term change; avoiding new silos and fragmentation; maintaining scientific legitimacy alongside explicit normative commitments; and retaining staff under insecure funding and administrative pressures. Taken together, these tensions show that the prospects of TOROs are shaped by three wider challenges facing research for transformation: weakening public and political legitimacy of research, difficulties in demonstrating relevance and contribution through conventional impact measures, and growing political and funding uncertainty.Keywords
This publication has 61 references indexed in Scilit:
- Reinterpreting scaling as synchronising and sequencing: A case study of food system innovation in eastern IndiaAgricultural Systems, 2026
- Science with purpose: Advancing mission-oriented research in academiaCell Reports Sustainability, 2025
- The emerging institutionalisation of knowledge co-production in sustainability researchAMBIO, 2025
- Scientific collaboration amid geopolitical tensions: a comparison of Sweden and AustraliaHigher Education, 2023
- Of temporality and plurality: an epistemic and governance agenda for accelerating just transitions for energy access and sustainable developmentCurrent Opinion in Environmental Sustainability, 2018
- Cassava Trait Preferences of Men and Women Farmers in Nigeria: Implications for BreedingEconomic Botany, 2018
- Mainstreaming climate adaptation: taking stock about “what works” from empirical research worldwideRegional Environmental Change, 2017
- The real type and ideal type of transdisciplinary processes: part I—theoretical foundationsSustainability Science, 2015
- Science with Society in the AnthropoceneAMBIO, 2013
- Public Value Mapping and Science Policy EvaluationMinerva, 2011