Encouraging Dialogue in Doctoral Supervision: The Development of the Feedback Expectation Tool
Open Access
- 1 January 2020
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Informing Science Institute in International Journal of Doctoral Studies
- Vol. 15, 265-284
Abstract
Aim/Purpose: This paper introduces the Feedback Expectation Tool (FET) as an easy-to-use and flexible pedagogical tool to encourage dialogue on feedback between supervisors and candidates. The main aim of this pedagogical innovation is to allow negotiation to understand expectations and establish boundaries through transparent practices. Background: Feedback is a key element of learning and development and vital to developing scholarship. The literature indicates that supervisors and candidates often have different expectations about feedback. We developed the FET as a tool to encourage dialogue on feedback between supervisors and candidates so that they could understand each other’s expectations, negotiate, and work together in the most beneficial way possible. Methodology: We sought qualitative survey data from doctoral supervisors and candidates attending two universities. Participants identified key issues they faced with feedback. Based on current literature, qualitative survey data, and our insights as feedback researchers and academic developers, we developed a list of 13 conflicting statements. From this, we created the FET. Contribution: This paper shows how the FET evolved as an educational, developmental tool. It includes the tool (the FET) for easy and immediate use by supervisors and candidates. The FET makes an innovative pedagogical contribution to supervision practice and the wider body of knowledge around these practices. Findings: The paper presents and discusses the 13 FET statements that are the synthesized result of the literature review, the analysis of the qualitative survey data, and our experience. Each statement has contradictions that offer opportunities for dialogue between the supervisor and the candidate. Recommendations for Practitioners: Supervisors can use the FET successfully as a pedagogical tool when talking with their doctoral candidates. Every supervisor and candidate will use the FET in a way that works best for them both. Recommendation for Researchers: Researchers could conduct studies in other research sites and countries and in specific disciplines. These studies would help us better understand the FET as a pedagogical tool so we could develop it further. Impact on Society: The FET is designed to help learning take place. It achieves this by creating a common understanding of the complexities in the feedback process. To keep up with ongoing changes in society in general, and in Higher Education and doctoral education in particular, we present the FET as a living document. Future Research: The authors are conducting follow-up research to discover how useful the FET is as a tool to help achieve more open and collegial feedback practices in doctoral supervision.Keywords
This publication has 30 references indexed in Scilit:
- Developing a learning-centred framework for feedback literacyAssessment & Evaluation in Higher Education, 2019
- The development of student feedback literacy: enabling uptake of feedbackAssessment & Evaluation in Higher Education, 2018
- Mentorship, supervision and learning experience in PhD educationStudies in Higher Education, 2011
- Challenging the taken-for-granted: how research analysis might inform pedagogical practices and institutional policies related to doctoral educationStudies in Higher Education, 2011
- A Model for Doctoral Students’ Perceptions and Attitudes Toward Written Feedback for Academic WritingResearch in Higher Education, 2010
- Doctoral supervision . . . a view from above, below and the middle!Journal of Further and Higher Education, 2008
- Formative assessment and self‐regulated learning: a model and seven principles of good feedback practiceStudies in Higher Education, 2006
- Creation of a Graduate Oral/Written Communication Skills CourseAmerican Journal of Pharmaceutical Education, 2006
- Teaching Graduate Students to Write: A seminar for thesis and dissertation writersJournal of Geography in Higher Education, 2003
- On the definition of feedbackSystems Research and Behavioral Science, 1983