Proportionality, Comparability, and Parity: A Discussion on the Rationality of Balancing
Open Access
- 1 December 2023
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Legal Theory
- Vol. 29 (4) , 257-288
Abstract
This article analyses the rationality of the principle of proportionality as a justificatory method for solving cases involving conflicts of constitutional principles. It addresses the “problem of comparability”: a set of arguments claiming that proportionalists fail to understand what happens when constitutional principles collide. The problem of comparability suggests that balancing cannot be done if some conflicts of constitutional principles are, in reality, cases of noncomparability, incommensurability, incomparability, or vagueness. In this article, I challenge the views of both proportionalists and their skeptics. Against the skeptics, I argue that proportionality can survive the challenge posed by the problem of comparability. Against the proportionalists, I submit that proportionality cannot be understood as a system of tradeoffs between degrees of satisfaction of principles. If comparison among constitutional principles is to be rational, we need a different approach to normativity—one that allows for the possibility of parity.Keywords
This publication has 13 references indexed in Scilit:
- Parity, Imprecise Comparability and the Repugnant ConclusionTheoria, 2016
- A Critique of ProportionalityThe American Journal of Jurisprudence, 2012
- Comparing the Incommensurable: Constitutional Principles, Balancing and Rational DecisionOxford Journal of Legal Studies, 2011
- Proportionality and Principled BalancingThe Law & Ethics of Human Rights, 2010
- Proportionality: An assault on human rights?International Journal of Constitutional Law, 2009
- PROPORTIONALITY AND VARIABLE INTENSITY OF REVIEWThe Cambridge Law Journal, 2006
- On Balancing and Subsumption. A Structural ComparisonRatio Juris, 2003
- The Possibility of ParityEthics, 2002
- Incommensurability and Valuation in LawMichigan Law Review, 1994
- Legal Principles and the Limits of LawThe Yale Law Journal, 1972