Evaluation of abilities in interpreting media reports of scientific research
Author:
- Mary RatcliffeMRMary Ratcliffe
- 1 October 1999
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in International Journal of Science Education
- Vol. 21 (10) , 1085-1099
Abstract
With development of ‘scientific literacy’ in mind, this study explored early secondary school pupils' written evaluations of media reports of contemporary science research in a classroom setting. Their abilities of evidence evaluation were contrasted with those of people with greater experience of science education-college science students and science graduates. The vast majority of each of these three groups distinguished between established facts and areas of uncertainty in media reports. A similar proportion of pupils and students (40%) showed logical but limited reasoning in recognizing the problems of extrapolating from insufficient evidence, with pupils perhaps aided by the pedagogical context. In contrast, 80% of science graduates reasoned logically invoking methodological limitations of the research evidence presented. There was little distinction between the nature and extent of pupils' and students' responses, except that only amongst pupils was personal experience invoked in reasoning. Results suggest that, at present, only through extensive experience of formal science education do skills of evidence evaluation develop fully. However, pupils and students exhibit the potential for abilities to be developed further through explicit teaching.Keywords
This publication has 14 references indexed in Scilit:
- Interpreting popular reports of science: what happens when the reader's world meets the world on paper?International Journal of Science Education, 1999
- Whose nature of science?Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 1997
- Self-Serving Influences on Adolescents’ Evaluations of Belief-Relevant EvidenceJournal of Experimental Child Psychology, 1996
- Reading and writing to learn science: Achieving scientific literacyJournal of Research in Science Teaching, 1994
- Interpreting pragmatic meaning when reading popular reports of scienceJournal of Research in Science Teaching, 1994
- The Role of Anomalous Data in Knowledge Acquisition: A Theoretical Framework and Implications for Science InstructionReview of Educational Research, 1993
- Children's judgments in theory choice tasks: Scientific rationality in childhoodCognition, 1992
- Lexical cohesion and specialized knowledge in science and popular science textsDiscourse Processes, 1991
- Structure of science popularizations: A genre-analysis approach to the schema of popularized medical textsEnglish for Specific Purposes, 1991
- Teaching readers about the structure of scientific text.Journal of Educational Psychology, 1988