Assembling Enclosure: Reading Marine Spatial Planning for Alternatives
- 10 August 2017
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Annals of the American Association of Geographers
- Vol. 108 (1) , 144-161
Abstract
Research on enclosure has often examined the phenomenon as a process and outcome of state, neoliberal, and hybrid territorial practices with detrimental impacts for those affected. The proliferation of increasingly complex environmental governance regimes and new enclosures, such as those now seen in the oceans, challenge these readings, however. Using the case of U.S. marine spatial planning (MSP), this article reexamines enclosure through the lens of assemblage. A comprehensive new approach to oceans governance based on spatial data and collaborative decision making, MSP appears to follow past governance programs toward a broad-scale rationalization and enclosure of U.S. waters. Yet this appearance might only be superficial. As an assemblage, U.S. MSP—and its shifting actors, associations, and practices—holds the potential to both close and open the seas for oceans communities, environments, and other actors. Planning actors use three practices to stabilize U.S. MSP for governance and enclosure: narrativizing MSP, creating a geospatial framework to underlie planning, and engaging stakeholders. These practices, however, simultaneously provide opportunities for communities and environments to intervene in U.S. MSP toward alternative outcomes. Rather than a closed seas, U.S. MSP presents opportunities for enclosure to happen differently or not at all, producing alternative outcomes for coastal and oceans communities, environments, and governance.Keywords
This publication has 63 references indexed in Scilit:
- The ontological politics of marine spatial planning: Assembling the ocean and shaping the capacities of ‘Community’ and ‘Environment’Geoforum, 2016
- Ocean grabbingMarine Policy, 2015
- Individual transferable quotas and conservation: a critical assessmentEcology and Society, 2015
- Oceans at Rio+20Conservation Letters, 2013
- Assembling the sea: materiality, movement and regulatory practices in the Cardigan Bay scallop fisheryCultural Geographies, 2012
- On assemblages and geographyDialogues in Human Geography, 2012
- Don't Fence Me In: Boundaries, Policy, and Deliberation in Maine's Lobster CommonsAnnals of the American Association of Geographers, 2012
- Assemblage and geographyArea, 2011
- Powerful assemblages?Area, 2011
- The limits of ‘neoliberal natures’: Debating green neoliberalismProgress in Human Geography, 2010