International Tuberculum Sellae Meningioma Study: Preoperative Grading Scale to Predict Outcomes and Propensity-Matched Outcomes by Endonasal Versus Transcranial Approach
Authors:
- Stephen T. MagillSMStephen T. Magill
- Theodore H. SchwartzTSTheodore H. Schwartz
- William T. CouldwellWCWilliam T. Couldwell
- Paul A. GardnerPGPaul A. Gardner
- Carl B. HeilmanCHCarl B. Heilman
- Chandranath SenCSChandranath Sen
- Ryojo AkagamiRARyojo Akagami
- Paolo CappabiancaPCPaolo Cappabianca
- Daniel M. PrevedelloDPDaniel M. Prevedello
- Michael W. McDermottMMMichael W. McDermott
- 7 July 2023
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wolters Kluwer Health in Neurosurgery
- Vol. 93 (6) , 1271-1284
Abstract
BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES: Tuberculum sellae meningiomas are resected via an expanded endonasal (EEA) or transcranial approach (TCA). Which approach provides superior outcomes is debated. The Magill–McDermott (M-M) grading scale evaluating tumor size, optic canal invasion, and arterial involvement remains to be validated for outcome prediction. The objective of this study was to validate the M-M scale for predicting visual outcome, extent of resection (EOR), and recurrence, and to use propensity matching by M-M scale to determine whether visual outcome, EOR, or recurrence differ between EEA and TCA. METHODS: Forty-site retrospective study of 947 patients undergoing tuberculum sellae meningiomas resection. Standard statistical methods and propensity matching were used. RESULTS: The M-M scale predicted visual worsening (odds ratio [OR]/point: 1.22, 95% CI: 1.02-1.46, P = .0271) and gross total resection (GTR) (OR/point: 0.71, 95% CI: 0.62-0.81, P < .0001), but not recurrence (P = .4695). The scale was simplified and validated in an independent cohort for predicting visual worsening (OR/point: 2.34, 95% CI: 1.33-4.14, P = .0032) and GTR (OR/point: 0.73, 95% CI: 0.57-0.93, P = .0127), but not recurrence (P = .2572). In propensity-matched samples, there was no difference in visual worsening (P = .8757) or recurrence (P = .5678) between TCA and EEA, but GTR was more likely with TCA (OR: 1.49, 95% CI: 1.02-2.18, P = .0409). Matched patients with preoperative visual deficits who had an EEA were more likely to have visual improvement than those undergoing TCA (72.9% vs 58.4%, P = .0010) with equal rates of visual worsening (EEA 8.0% vs TCA 8.6%, P = .8018). CONCLUSION: The refined M-M scale predicts visual worsening and EOR preoperatively. Preoperative visual deficits are more likely to improve after EEA; however, individual tumor features must be considered during nuanced approach selection by experienced neurosurgeons.Keywords
This publication has 10 references indexed in Scilit:
- Residual and Recurrent Disease Following Endoscopic Endonasal Approach as a Reflection of Anatomic Limitation for the Resection of Midline Anterior Skull Base MeningiomasOperative Neurosurgery, 2021
- Endoscopic Endonasal and Supraorbital Removal of Tuberculum Sellae Meningiomas: Anatomic Guides and Operative Nuances for Keyhole Approach SelectionOperative Neurosurgery, 2021
- Endoscopic endonasal approach for suprasellar meningiomas: introduction of a new scoring system to predict extent of resection and assist in case selection with long-term outcome dataJournal of Neurosurgery, 2020
- Transsphenoidal versus Transcranial Approach for Treatment of Tuberculum Sellae Meningiomas: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis of Comparative StudiesScientific Reports, 2019
- Tuberculum sellae meningiomas: grading scale to assess surgical outcomes using the transcranial versus transsphenoidal approachNeurosurgical Focus, 2018
- Endoscopic endonasal versus transcranial approach to tuberculum sellae and planum sphenoidale meningiomas in a similar cohort of patientsJournal of Neurosurgery, 2018
- Direct visualization of improved optic nerve pial vascular supply following tuberculum meningioma resection: case reportJournal of Neurosurgery, 2016
- Meningiomas: knowledge base, treatment outcomes, and uncertainties. A RANO reviewJournal of Neurosurgery, 2015
- Strengthening the Reporting of Observational Studies in Epidemiology (STROBE): Explanation and elaborationInternational Journal of Surgery, 2014
- THE RECURRENCE OF INTRACRANIAL MENINGIOMAS AFTER SURGICAL TREATMENTJournal of Neurology, Neurosurgery & Psychiatry, 1957