Use of peer assessment in tooth extraction competency
Authors:
- 23 May 2013
- journal article
- Published by Wiley in European Journal of Dental Education
- Vol. 18 (1) , 44-50
Abstract
Peer assessment is a widely recognised practice in higher education and is being increasingly utilised in healthcare education. It offers multiple advantages and may play a useful role in enhancing students' learning experience. This study was carried out to evaluate the utility of peer assessment in tooth extraction competency in simulated dental learning environment (SDLE). Year 2 dental students were invited to participate in a formative, peer assessment exercise on forceps tooth extraction in SDLE. The ratings made by peers in the formative assessment were compared with the ratings made by academic supervisors in an equivalent summative assessment. One hundred and twenty-two students participated in both the formative and summative assessments. Descriptive statistics demonstrated that the majority of students were given the same rating in both assessments. However, there were a number of students who were rated as 'Competent' in one assessment and 'Not Competent' in the other assessment. Spearman's Rho correlations showed that there were weak relationships between the formative and summative assessments. There was also weak inter-rater reliability for the ratings of the peers and academic supervisors, as measured by the intraclass correlation coefficient. Feedback from the students and academic supervisors showed unanimously positive perceptions about the peer assessment experience, and they expressed the desire for incorporating peer assessment in other competencies. This study shows mixed results with regard to the value of the peer assessment. Given the potential utility of peer assessment as a tool to augment and enrich students' learning experience, further work needs to be done to evaluate the use of peer assessment in operative competencies in dentistry.Keywords
This publication has 27 references indexed in Scilit:
- Pharmacy Students’ Perceptions of and Attitudes Towards Peer Assessment Within a Drug Literature Evaluation CourseAmerican Journal of Pharmaceutical Education, 2012
- Psychometric Properties of a Peer-Assessment Program to Assess Continuing Competence in Physical TherapyPhysical Therapy, 2010
- Peer Assessment of Professionalism: A Five-Year Experience in Medical ClerkshipJournal of General Internal Medicine, 2009
- Peer‐group assessment of pre‐clinical operative skills in restorative dentistry and comparison with experienced assessorsEuropean Journal of Dental Education, 2008
- Medical students’ perceptions of peer feedback on an anatomy student-selected study moduleMedical Teacher, 2008
- The reliability of measuring physical characteristics of spiculated masses on mammographyBritish Journal of Radiology, 2006
- Peer Assessment in Problem-Based Learning: A Qualitative StudyAdvances in Health Sciences Education, 2006
- Validity of objective tests towards peer-rated competence by studentsMedical Teacher, 2003
- Comparison of faculty, peer, self, and nurse assessment of obstetrics and gynecology residents2002
- Student Peer Assessment in Higher Education: A Meta-Analysis Comparing Peer and Teacher MarksReview of Educational Research, 2000