Prevention of bedside errors in transfusion medicine (PROBE‐TM) study: a cluster‐randomized, matched‐paired clinical areas trial of a simple intervention to reduce errors in the pretransfusion bedside check
Authors:
- Michael F. MurphyMMMichael F. Murphy
- Angela C. CasbardACAngela C. Casbard
- Sally BallardSBSally Ballard
- Ira A. ShulmanISIra A. Shulman
- Nancy HeddleNHNancy Heddle
- James P. AubuchonJAJames P. Aubuchon
- Silvano WendelSWSilvano Wendel
- Amanda ThomsonATAmanda Thomson
- Tor HervigTHTor Hervig
- Katharine DownesKDKatharine Downes
- Patricia M. CareyPCPatricia M. Carey
- Walter H. DzikWDWalter H. Dzik
- 25 April 2007
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Transfusion
- Vol. 47 (5) , 771-780
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Transfusion of the incorrect blood component is a frequent serious incident associated with transfusion and often involves misidentification of the patient and/or the unit of blood. The objective of this study was to assess the effect of a simple intervention designed to improve performance of the bedside check and to observe the durability of any effect. The intervention was a tag on blood bags reminding staff to check the patient's wristband. The tag was positioned in such a way that the transfusionist was required to remove the tag to spike the unit.STUDY DESIGN AND METHODS: The intervention was tested in a multicenter cluster‐randomized controlled trial incorporating short‐term and long‐term follow‐up periods. The primary endpoint was the proportion of patients transfused with red cell units for whom the key elements of the bedside check were all correctly completed.RESULTS: Fifteen matched‐paired clinical areas at 12 participating hospitals in six countries were included in the trial. Combining data from all participating hospitals, the bedside check was correctly performed in 37 percent of transfusions during the baseline audit period. There was no evidence of a favorable effect of the intervention immediately after its introduction (pooled odds ratio, 1.09; 95% confidence interval, 0.54‐2.17). There was similarly no evidence of a favorable effect after continued use of the intervention for an additional 8 weeks.CONCLUSIONS: A simple intervention in the form of a barrier warning label on blood bags reminding staff to check the patient's wristband failed to improve bedside transfusion practice. The robust study design developed for this study could be applied to investigate other interventions to improve the safety of bedside transfusion practice.Keywords
This publication has 13 references indexed in Scilit:
- A comprehensive assessment program to improve blood‐administering practices using the FOCUS–PDCA modelTransfusion, 2004
- Emily Cooley Lecture 2002: transfusion safety in the hospitalTransfusion, 2003
- Barcode technology: its role in increasing the safety of blood transfusionTransfusion, 2003
- Errors in Interpreting the Pretransfusion Bedside Compatibility TestVox Sanguinis, 2000
- A cost-effectiveness analysis of the use of a mechanical barrier system to reduce the risk of mistransfusionTransfusion, 1996
- Bedside Transfusion Errors: Analysis of 2 Years' Use of a System to Monitor and Prevent Transfusion ErrorsVox Sanguinis, 1996
- Errors in blood transfusion in Britain: survey of hospital haematology departmentsBMJ, 1994
- Bedside Transfusion ErrorsVox Sanguinis, 1994
- Improvement in transfusion safety using a new blood unit and patient identification system as part of safe transfusion practiceTransfusion, 1991
- Reports of 355 transfusion‐associated deaths: 1976 through 1985Transfusion, 1990