Comparing Methods for Identifying Post-Market Patient Preferences at the Point of Decision-Making: Insights from Patients with Chronic Pain Considering a Spinal Cord Stimulator Device
Authors:
- Elizabeth H GolembiewskiEGElizabeth H Golembiewski
- Montserrat Leon-GarciaMLMontserrat Leon-Garcia
- Derek Loy GravholtDGDerek Loy Gravholt
- Juan P BritoJBJuan P Brito
- Erica S SpatzESErica S Spatz
- Markus BendelMBMarkus Bendel
- Victor M MontoriVMVictor M Montori
- Andrea P MarabotoAMAndrea P Maraboto
- Sandra HartasanchezSHSandra Hartasanchez
- Ian G HargravesIHIan G Hargraves
Open Access
- 1 June 2024
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Patient Preference and Adherence
- Vol. ume 18, 1325-1344
Abstract
Purpose: To compare three methods for identifying patient preferences (MIPPs) at the point of decision-making: analysis of video-recorded patient-clinician encounters, post-encounter interviews, and post-encounter surveys. Patients and Methods: For the decision of whether to use a spinal cord stimulator device (SCS), a video coding scheme, interview guide, and patient survey were iteratively developed with 30 SCS decision-making encounters in a tertiary academic medical center pain clinic. Burke’s grammar of motives was used to classify the attributed source or justification for a potential preference for each preference block. To compare the MIPPs, 13 patients’ encounters with their clinician were video recorded and subsequently analyzed by 4 coders using the final video coding scheme. Six of these patients were interviewed, and 7 surveyed, immediately following their encounters. Results: For videos, an average of 66 (range 33– 106) sets of utterances potentially indicating a patient preference (a preference block), surveys 33 (range 32– 34), and interviews 25 (range 18– 30) were identified. Thirty-eight unique themes (75 subthemes), each a preference topic, were identified from videos, surveys 19 themes (12 subthemes), and interviews 39 themes (54 subthemes). The proportion of preference blocks that were judged as expressing a preference that was clearly important to the patient or affected their decision was highest for interviews (72.8%), surveys (68.0%), and videos (27.0%). Videos mostly attributed preferences to the patient’s situation (scene) (65%); interviews, the act of receiving or living with SCS (43%); surveys, the purpose of SCS (40%). Conclusion: MIPPs vary in the type of preferences identified and the clarity of expressed preferences in their data sets. The choice of which MIPP to use depends on projects’ goals and resources, recognizing that the choice of MIPP may affect which preferences are found.Keywords
This publication has 19 references indexed in Scilit:
- Co-creating sensible care plans using shared decision making: Patients’ reflections and observations of encountersPatient Education and Counseling, 2022
- Advancing the Use of Patient Preference Information as Scientific Evidence in Medical Product Evaluation: A Summary Report of the Patient Preference WorkshopThe Patient - Patient-Centered Outcomes Research, 2019
- Methods for exploring and eliciting patient preferences in the medical product lifecycle: a literature reviewDrug Discovery Today, 2019
- Factors and situations influencing the value of patient preference studies along the medical product lifecycle: a literature reviewDrug Discovery Today, 2019
- A Framework for Incorporating Patient Preferences Regarding Benefits and Risks into Regulatory Assessment of Medical TechnologiesValue in Health, 2016
- Engaging Patients Across the Spectrum of Medical Product DevelopmentJAMA, 2015
- The Influence of Race and Gender on Pain Management: A Systematic Literature ReviewPain Management Nursing, 2015
- The Optimal Practice of Evidence-Based MedicineJAMA, 2013
- Doctor–patient communication about drugs: the evidence for shared decision makingSocial Science & Medicine, 2000
- Verbal analysis of doctor-patient communicationSocial Science & Medicine, 1991