Validation as a Pragmatic, Scientific Activity
Author:
- 14 March 2013
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Educational Measurement
- Vol. 50 (1) , 115-122
Abstract
This response to the comments contains three main sections, each addressing a subset of the comments. In the first section, I will respond to the comments by Brennan, Haertel, and Moss. All of these comments suggest ways in which my presentation could be extended or improved; I generally agree with their suggestions, so my response to their comments is brief. In the second section, I will respond to suggestions by Newton and Sireci that my framework be simplified by employing only one kind of argument, a validity argument, and dropping the interpretation/use argument (IUA); I am sympathetic to their desire for greater simplicity, but I see considerable value in keeping the IUA as a framework for the validation effort and will argue for keeping both the IUA and the validity argument. In the third section, I will respond to Borsboom and Markus, who raise a fundamental objection to my approach to validation, suggesting that I give too much attention to justification and too little to truth as a criterion for validity; I don't accept their proposed conception of validity, and I will indicate why.Keywords
This publication has 6 references indexed in Scilit:
- The Concept of Validity.Psychological Review, 2004
- Validating Interpretive Arguments for Licensure and Certification ExaminationsEvaluation & the Health Professions, 1994
- Evaluating Test ValidityReview of Research in Education, 1993
- The real test bias: Influences of testing on teaching and learning.American Psychologist, 1984
- Criticism and the Growth of Knowledge1970
- Falsification and the Methodology of Scientific Research Programmes1970