Comment on “Communication: Is directed percolation in colloid–polymer mixtures linked to dynamic arrest?” [J. Chem. Phys. 148, 241101 (2018)]
- 12 July 2022
- journal article
- editorial
- Published by AIP Publishing in The Journal of Chemical Physics
- Vol. 157 (2) , 027101
Abstract
In their Communication [J. Chem. Phys. 148, 241101 (2018)], Richard et al. state that in the work of Kohl et al. [Nat. Commun. 7, 11817 (2016)], a mechanism for dynamical arrest in temporal networks has been proposed that actually has never been proposed (and would be obviously wrong) in this context. The actual findings of Kohl et al. are not tested nor affected by the communication. The work of Richard et al. rests on simulations in a regime of the phase diagram that significantly differs from the one that Kohl et al. consider. In this Comment, it is shown that both the effective density and the rescaled second virial coefficient indicate that the comparison presented by Richard et al. is invalid. Therefore, the implications that are based on this comparison are incorrect. There is no indication for a disagreement between the simulations of Richard et al. and those of Kohl et al., and I am confident that upon consistent comparison and interpretation of the results, both works can contribute to a more comprehensive picture of gel-forming systems.Keywords
This publication has 10 references indexed in Scilit:
- Structural and dynamical properties of dilute gel networks in colloid–polymer mixturesThe Journal of Chemical Physics, 2021
- Communication: Is directed percolation in colloid-polymer mixtures linked to dynamic arrest?The Journal of Chemical Physics, 2018
- Shear-induced slab-like domains in a directed percolated colloidal gelThe European Physical Journal E, 2017
- Directed percolation identified as equilibrium pre-transition towards non-equilibrium arrested gel statesNature Communications, 2016
- Homogeneous percolation versus arrested phase separation in attractively-driven nanoemulsion colloidal gelsSoft Matter, 2014
- Phase behavior of a fluid with competing attractive and repulsive interactionsPhysical Review E, 2007
- Competition of Percolation and Phase Separation in a Fluid of Adhesive Hard SpheresPhysical Review Letters, 2003
- Simulation study of nonergodicity transitions: Gelation in colloidal systems with short-range attractionsPhysical Review E, 2003
- Extended corresponding-states behavior for particles with variable range attractionsThe Journal of Chemical Physics, 2000
- What is "liquid"? Understanding the states of matterReviews of Modern Physics, 1976