Classroom Culture Wars: Experimental Evidence of the Influence of Religion on Educational Content Regulation and Punishment
Open Access
Abstract
The intersection of religion and education in the United States dates to colonial times, as do attempts by religious institutions and individuals to regulate educational content. After a prominent retreat by religious fundamentalists following the Scopes Monkey Trial, conservative Christians have once again entered political debates about educational content in the form of modern culture wars issues. Both conservatives and liberals have attempted to punish educators for political comments made in class, but the influence of religion on individual attitudes has yet to be examined. In this article, we use an original survey experiment to examine individuals’ propensity to punish a professor who makes politically charged comments in class. We also assess whether religious individuals are more likely to punish professors for comments disparaging conservatives or liberals. We find that high-attending religious individuals, including both Evangelicals and Catholics, are more likely to support punishing the professor. However, we find that the propensity to punish is not related to the target of the professor’s comments. These findings suggest a resurgence of religious interest in education as a cultural issue at the individual, and not just institutional, level and a coalition between Evangelicals and Catholics on this issue.Keywords
This publication has 76 references indexed in Scilit:
- Assessing the Effect of Media Tone on Attitudes Toward Muslims: Evidence From an Online ExperimentPolitics and Religion, 2022
- Whose agenda is it anyway: an exploration of cancel culture and political affiliation in the United StatesSN Social Sciences, 2021
- Gender, Religion, and Pro-Life ActivismPolitics and Religion, 2020
- American Constitutional Faith and the Politics of HermeneuticsPolitics and Religion, 2019
- Self-stereotyping as “Evangelical Republican”: An Empirical TestPolitics and Religion, 2013
- Beliefs about God, the afterlife and morality support the role of supernatural policing in human cooperationEvolution and Human Behavior, 2011
- Instructional manipulation checks: Detecting satisficing to increase statistical powerJournal of Experimental Social Psychology, 2009
- Academic Freedom in Higher Education Within a Conservative Sociopolitical CultureInnovative Higher Education, 2006
- Terrorists and witches: popular ideas of evil in the early modern periodHistory of European Ideas, 2004
- Salvation or damnation?: Religion and correctional ideologyAmerican Journal of Criminal Justice, 2003