Daring to dream: reactions to tobacco endgame ideas among policy-makers, media and public health practitioners
Open Access
- 20 July 2011
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in BMC Public Health
- Vol. 11 (1) , 580
Abstract
Tobacco control strategies have mainly targeted reducing demand. Supply-side focused measures, though less familiar, deserve consideration, particularly to achieve 'endgame' tobacco control aims (e.g. achieving close to zero smoking prevalence). We explored attitudes towards supply-side focused 'endgame' tobacco control approaches and how they can be best communicated with senior policymakers, journalists, and public health practitioners. We identified five supply-side focused approaches which could potentially lead to the tobacco endgame: two structural models and three discrete actions. The structural models were: (i) a Nicotine Authority to coordinate tobacco control activities and regulate the nicotine/tobacco market for public health aims; and (ii) a Tobacco Supply Agency acting as a monopoly purchaser of tobacco products and controlling the tobacco supply for public health aims. The actions were: (a) allocating progressively reducing tobacco product import quotas (the 'sinking lid') until importation and commercial sale of tobacco products ceased; (b) making tobacco companies responsible for reducing smoking prevalence with stringent financial penalties if targets were missed; and (c) new laws to facilitate litigation against tobacco companies. These approaches were presented as means to achieve a tobacco free New Zealand by 2020 to 19 senior policymakers, journalists, and public health physicians in two focus groups and eight interviews, and their reactions sought. The tobacco-free vision was widely supported. Participants engaged fully with the proposed tobacco control approaches, which were viewed as interesting or even intriguing. Most supported increasing the focus on supply-side measures. Views differed greatly about the desirability, feasibility and likely effectiveness of each approach. Participants identified a range of potential barriers to implementation and challenges to successfully advocating and communicating these approaches. The current framing of tobacco as a risky but legal commodity was noted as an important potential barrier to implementing endgame approaches. Endgame tobacco control approaches were considered to be viable policy options. Further policy analysis, research and public discussion are needed to develop endgame approaches. A significant change in the public framing of tobacco may be a prerequisite for implementing endgame solutions.Keywords
This publication has 25 references indexed in Scilit:
- Outlet density: a new frontier for tobacco controlAddiction, 2008
- Why not seek clever regulation? A reply to LibermanTobacco Control, 2006
- Going smoke-free: the medical case for clean air in the home, at work and in public placesClinical Medicine, 2005
- To burn or not to burn: an advocate’s report from the fieldInjury Prevention, 2005
- Canada gets its house in orderInjury Prevention, 2005
- Transforming the tobacco market: why the supply of cigarettes should be transferred from for-profit corporations to non-profit enterprises with a public health mandate: Table 1Tobacco Control, 2005
- Toward a comprehensive long term nicotine policyTobacco Control, 2005
- Taming the tigers: the case for controlling the tobacco marketAddiction, 2004
- A strategy for controlling the marketing of tobacco products: a regulated market modelTobacco Control, 2003
- Regulatory imbalance between medicinal and non-medicinal nicotineAddiction, 2000