The Identification of Students Who Are Gifted and Have a Learning Disability: A Comparison of Different Diagnostic Criteria
- 24 January 2018
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Gifted Child Quarterly
- Vol. 62 (2) , 175-192
Abstract
Students who are gifted and have a learning disability (GLD) may not be identified, in part because of disagreement regarding appropriate identification criteria. In this study, suggested GLD identification criteria were applied to a nationally representative sample of school-age students to determine the number and characteristics of students identified by each set of GLD criteria. Many but not all students identified as potentially GLD had relative weaknesses in lower order processing abilities and achievement, as hypothesized for this population. Students also exhibited academic strengths, which suggests dual differentiation would be appropriate. Commonly used intraindividual discrepancy criteria identified most potentially gifted students as potentially learning disabled; therefore, these are not valid stand-alone criteria to identify learning disabilities in gifted youth. Results suggest it may be best to combine alternative gifted criteria, an intraindividual LD criterion, and examination of absolute deficits in processing and achievement. Additional implications for research and practice are discussed.Keywords
This publication has 65 references indexed in Scilit:
- Comparing Prospective Twice-Exceptional Students With High-Performing Peers on High-Stakes Tests of AchievementJournal for the Education of the Gifted, 2015
- The Incidence of Potentially Gifted Students Within a Special Education PopulationRoeper Review, 2015
- The Advocacy Experiences of Parents of Elementary Age, Twice-Exceptional ChildrenGifted Child Quarterly, 2015
- Differences Between Children With Dyslexia Who Are and Are Not Gifted in Verbal ReasoningGifted Child Quarterly, 2013
- Twice-Exceptionality: Implications for School Psychologists in the Post–IDEA 2004 EraJournal of Applied School Psychology, 2011
- Programming for Mathematically Gifted Children With Learning DifficultiesRoeper Review, 2010
- Why Isn't Talent Development on the IEP? SEM and the Twice Exceptional LearnerGifted Education International, 2010
- Cognitive and Psychosocial Characteristics of Gifted Students With Written Language DisabilityGifted Child Quarterly, 2010
- The Impact of Vulnerabilities and Strengths on the Academic Experiences of Twice-Exceptional Students: A Message to School CounselorsProfessional School Counseling, 2006
- Gifted but Learning Disabled: A Puzzling ParadoxPreventing School Failure: Alternative Education for Children and Youth, 1989