The exaggerated radiocarbon age of deposit‐feeding molluscs in calcareous environments
Abstract
Throughout northernCanada, live‐collected, pre‐bomb, deposit‐feeding marine molluscs from calcareous sediments yield greater apparent radiocarbon ages than do suspension feeders. We explore the size of this effect in a set of 57 paired datings of deposit feeders, mainlyPortlandia arctica, and suspension feeders, mainlyHiatella arcticaandMya truncata, collected from both calcareous and non‐calcareousHolocene sediments. Deposit feeders from calcareous sediments are older than their suspension‐feeding counterparts by as much as 2240±13014Cyears. This is attributed to the uptake of ‘old’ bicarbonate derived from calcareous bedrock. The age discrepancy between suspension and deposit feeders in calcareous terrain is non‐systematic in space and time, thereby invalidating the application of a correction. In contrast, the age comparisons are concordant at sites located on thePrecambrian Shield. In terrestrial environments underlain by carbonate, previous acceptance of dates on deposit feeders led to erroneous interpretations of deglaciation and relative sea‐level history, in both theNorthAmerican and theEurasianArctic. This has prompted several researchers to exclude deposit feeders from their lateQuaternary reconstructions. The same chronological problem of deposit‐feeding molluscs now needs to be more widely acknowledged by the marine community.Keywords
This publication has 59 references indexed in Scilit:
- The Innuitian Ice Sheet: configuration, dynamics and chronologyQuaternary Science Reviews, 2006
- Late Wisconsinan buildup and wastage of the Innuitian Ice Sheet across southern Ellesmere Island, NunavutCanadian Journal of Earth Sciences, 2004
- The Laurentide and Innuitian ice sheets during the Last Glacial MaximumQuaternary Science Reviews, 2002
- The last glaciation of east-central Ellesmere Island, Nunavut: ice dynamics, deglacial chronology, and sea level changeCanadian Journal of Earth Sciences, 2000
- Quaternary history of Axel Heiberg Island bordering Nansen Sound, Northwest Territories, emphasizing the last glacial maximumCanadian Journal of Earth Sciences, 1998
- Glacier dynamics and paleoclimatic change during the last glaciation of eastern Ellesmere Island, CanadaCanadian Journal of Earth Sciences, 1996
- The influence of microhabitats on the carbon isotopic composition of deep‐sea benthic foraminiferaPaleoceanography and Paleoclimatology, 1990
- The late Quaternary history of Greely Fiord and its tributaries, west-central Ellesmere IslandCanadian Journal of Earth Sciences, 1990
- The late Quaternary history of Hall Land, northwest GreenlandCanadian Journal of Earth Sciences, 1985
- Neoglacial Fluctuations of Glaciers, Southeastern Ellesmere Island, Canadian Arctic ArchipelagoGeografiska Annaler: Series A, Physical Geography, 1981