Citizens’ data afterlives: Practices of dataset inclusion in machine learning for public welfare
Open Access
- 10 April 2024
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in AI & SOCIETY
- Vol. 40 (3) , 1183-1193
Abstract
Public sector adoption of AI techniques in welfare systems recasts historic national data as resource for machine learning. In this paper, we examine how the use of register data for development of predictive models produces new ‘afterlives’ for citizen data. First, we document a Danish research project’s practical efforts to develop an algorithmic decision-support model for social workers to classify children’s risk of maltreatment. Second, we outline the tensions emerging from project members’ negotiations about which datasets to include. Third, we identify three types of afterlives for citizen data in machine learning projects: (1) data afterlives for training and testing the algorithm, acting as ‘ground truth’ for inferring futures, (2) data afterlives for validating the algorithmic model, acting as markers of robustness, and (3) data afterlives for improving the model’s fairness, valuated for reasons of data ethics. We conclude by discussing how, on one hand, these afterlives engender new ethical relations between state and citizens; and how they, on the other hand, also articulate an alternative view on the value of datasets, posing interesting contrasts between machine learning projects developed within the context of the Danish welfare state and mainstream corporate AI discourses of the bigger, the better.Keywords
Funding Information
- Velux Fonden (Algorithms, Data, Democracy)
- IRFD - International Research Fund Denmark (9131-00115B: AI Reuse, 0132-00080B: Datafied Living)
- Aarhus Universitet
This publication has 46 references indexed in Scilit:
- Data as Relation: Ontological Trouble in the Data-Driven Public AdministrationComputer Supported Cooperative Work (CSCW), 2023
- Machine learning political ordersReview of International Studies, 2022
- Data and its (dis)contents: A survey of dataset development and use in machine learning researchPatterns, 2021
- Information In-Formation: Algorithmic Policing and the Life of Data2021
- Data and rights in the digital welfare state: the case of DenmarkInformation, Communication & Society, 2021
- Informal pathways as a response to limitations in formal categorization of referrals in child and family welfareNordic Social Work Research, 2020
- Datafied child welfare services: unpacking politics, economics and powerPolicy Studies, 2020
- Data Journeys in the Sciences2020
- Archival encounters: rethinking access and care in digital colonial archivesArchival Science, 2019
- Data Labours: How the Sequence Databases GenBank and EMBL-Bank Make DataScience as Culture, 2016