Redundant Publication?

Authors:
  • DFD J Federman
    D J Federman
  • AMA B Mutgi
    A B Mutgi

Abstract
The study by Lau et al. (July 23 issue)1 on the use of cumulative meta-analysis to determine clinical efficacy or harm presents an important concept in the analysis of clinical trials. The sequential combination of multiple small studies allows one to increase the size of the available sample and determine the statistical significance. This excellent report is marred by the fact that the same authors have published these data and conclusions in the Journal of the American Medical Association (JAMA), with only the slightest of variations.2 These data are clearly an unmodified subset of those in the JAMA article, and are fully contained within it. In addition, there is no acknowledgment of the partial publication of the data in either of these articles. In the quest for academic achievement, promotion, and scholarly activity, a duplicate publication may seem reasonable but remains unethical.