Landscape governance as policy integration ‘from below’: A case of displaced and contained political conflict in the Netherlands
- 29 October 2015
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy
- Vol. 34 (3) , 448-462
Abstract
Agrienvironmental schemes (AES) have been a predominant manifestation of environmental policy Integration in the EU. However, rather than strictly following formal AES policy, farmers across Europe have taken various other initiatives to integrate environmental and agricultural practices. Mostly, these integrative initiatives were based on dynamic actor networks at various levels, responding to local problems and challenges. Compared with situations where, from the top down, one (mostly weaker) policy domain is integrated into another, the kind of integration taking place in these examples may be called more ‘fundamental’. Here, integration is already embedded in the practical outcomes envisioned in specific places. The parts of the outcome require each other. However, this fundamental form of integration may render problems at other levels and sectors of governance. In this paper we present a case study of an initiative called Farming for Nature. The initiative aimed to integrate farming and nature more thoroughly than EU and national policies and incorporated some important other characteristics of the area, such as its water dynamics and relationships with the urban environment. However, it also involved some key differences from mainstream policy; and although it resonated with EU support for participative governance, these differences rendered a lengthy process towards implementation lasting more than half a decade. We use the concept of ‘landscape governance’—operationalized as the interplay of discourses, institutional practices, and natural–spatial conditions—to understand the politics of scale involved when mainstream government policies and local integrative initiatives meet. Particular attention is paid to how the local ideas toned down some of their integrative ingredients in order to comply with mainstream sectoral policy discourse. We find that the type of landscape governance implemented shaped the initiatives into a form that contributed to their implementation, but simultaneously displaced and contained political conflict in a way that prevented public debate.Keywords
This publication has 24 references indexed in Scilit:
- Making Sense of EU State Aid Requirements: The Case of Green ServicesEnvironment and Planning C: Government and Policy, 2010
- Environmental policy integration: a state of the art reviewEnvironmental Policy and Governance, 2010
- Deciding how to decide on agri-environmental schemes: the political economy of subsidiarity, decentralisation and participation in the European UnionJournal of Environmental Planning and Management, 2009
- Integrated landscape planning and remuneration of agri-environmental servicesJournal of Environmental Management, 2008
- Rewarding farmers for delivering vascular plant diversity in managed grasslands: A transdisciplinary case-study approachBiological Conservation, 2008
- Unpicking Environmental Policy Integration with Tales from Waste ManagementEnvironment and Planning C: Government and Policy, 2008
- ANALYSING THE SUCCESS OF OPEN SPACE PRESERVATION IN THE NETHERLANDS: THE MIDDEN‐DELFLAND CASETijdschrift Voor Economische En Sociale Geografie, 2008
- Controlled Decontrolling: Involution and Democratisation in Dutch Rural PlanningPlanning Theory & Practice, 2007
- Landscape as a ProvocationJournal of Material Culture, 2006
- Landscape as a Focus for Integrating Human and Environmental ProcessesJournal of Agricultural Economics, 2006