Thinking Beyond the Default User: The Impact of Gender, Stereotypes, and Modality on Interpretation of User Needs
- 29 January 2024
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Mechanical Design
- Vol. 146 (5) , 1-39
Abstract
Throughout the mechanical design process, designers, the majority of whom are men, often fail to consider the needs of women, resulting in consequences ranging from inconvenience to increased risk of serious injury or death. Although these biases are well studied in other fields of research, the mechanical design field lacks formal investigation into this phenomenon. In this study, engineering students (n = 301) took a survey in which they read a Persona describing a student makerspace user and a Walkthrough describing the user’s interaction with the makerspace while completing a project. During the Walkthrough, the user encountered various obstacles or Pain Points. Participants were asked to recall and evaluate the Pain Points that the user encountered and then evaluated their perceptions of the makerspace and user. The independent variables under investigation were the gender of the user Persona (woman, gender-neutral, or man), the Walkthrough room case (crafting or woodworking makerspace), and the modality of the Persona and Walkthrough (text- or audio-based). Results showed that participants from the Text-based modality were better able to recall Pain Points compared to participants from the Audio-based modality. Pain Points were assessed as more severe when they impacted women users, potentially stemming from protective paternalism. In addition to finding that the gender of a user impacted the way a task environment was perceived, results confirmed the presence of androcentrism, or “default man” assumptions, in the way designers view end users of unknown gender. Promisingly, providing user Persona information in an audio modality significantly reduced this bias compared to text-based modalities, indicating that providing richer detail in user personas has the capability to reduce gender bias in designers.Keywords
Funding Information
- Division of Graduate Education (2039655)
This publication has 43 references indexed in Scilit:
- Science faculty’s subtle gender biases favor male studentsProceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 2012
- An Experimental Study of the Effects of Stereotype Threat and Stereotype Lift on Men and Women's Performance in MathematicsThe Journal of Experimental Education, 2012
- Interventions That Affect Gender Bias in Hiring: A Systematic ReviewAcademic Medicine, 2009
- Ambient belonging: How stereotypical cues impact gender participation in computer science.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 2009
- Backlash effects for disconfirming gender stereotypes in organizationsResearch in Organizational Behavior, 2008
- Signaling ThreatPsychological Science, 2007
- Designing health communication: Testing the explanations for the impact of communication medium on effectivenessBritish Journal of Health Psychology, 2000
- Remembering science: The recall of factual information as a function of the presentation modeApplied Cognitive Psychology, 1990
- Multiple Comparisons Using Rank SumsTechnometrics, 1964
- The serial position effect of free recall.Journal of Experimental Psychology, 1962