Limitations of mild traumatic brain injury meta-analyses
Authors:
- Kelly M. JamesKJKelly M. James
- Erin D. BiglerEBErin D. Bigler
- 1 January 2009
- journal article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Brain Injury
- Vol. 23 (6) , 498-508
Abstract
Mild traumatic brain injury (mTBI) meta-analyses are sometimes cited as evidence that by 3 months post-injury the clinical effects are insignificant. In contrast to these conclusions are findings that long-term mTBI outcome can vary depending on (1) the mechanism of the injury, (2) which diagnostic criteria are employed, (3) which assessment tools utilized and (4) whether symptomatic groups are considered separately. The present study was designed to clarify opposing conclusions in the mTBI literature by re-analysing meta-analytic datasets. The most frequently cited mTBI meta-analysis is by Binder, Rohling and Larrabee in 1997; this study was updated in 2005 by Frencham, Fox and Maybery. Data combined in these studies were re-categorized according to the four variables above; associated effect sizes and heterogeneity statistics were calculated. Considerable qualitative and statistical heterogeneity was identified within the meta-analytic data under consideration. Clinically significant lasting effects were identified for a sub-set of neuropsychological measures. Methodological and statistical heterogeneity in studies combined in mTBI meta-analyses significantly limits the conclusions that can be drawn from small or non-significant overall effect sizes; clinically relevant information can be obscured by meta-analytic procedures. Recommendations for future meta-analytic studies of mTBI are offered.Keywords
This publication has 80 references indexed in Scilit:
- Traumatic brain injury: the signature of modern conflictsThe Lancet Neurology, 2008
- Mild Traumatic Brain Injury in U.S. Soldiers Returning from IraqNew England Journal of Medicine, 2008
- Military TBI During the Iraq and Afghanistan WarsJournal of Head Trauma Rehabilitation, 2006
- Functional Outcome in TBI I: Neuropsychological, Emotional, and Behavioral MediatorsJournal of Clinical and Experimental Neuropsychology, 2006
- Outcome from mild traumatic brain injuryCurrent Opinion in Psychiatry, 2005
- Neuropsychological Studies of Mild Traumatic Brain Injury: A Meta-Analytic Review of Research Since 1995Journal of Clinical and Experimental Neuropsychology, 2005
- Mild traumatic brain injury in the United States, 1998–2000Brain Injury, 2005
- A quantitative review of the effects of traumatic brain injury on cognitive functioningInternational Review of Psychiatry, 2003
- Clinical Neuropsychology in the Criminal Forensic SettingJournal of Head Trauma Rehabilitation, 2000
- A review of mild head trauma. part I: Meta-analytic review of neuropsychological studiesJournal of Clinical and Experimental Neuropsychology, 1997