Catechol-O-Methyl-Transferase Functional Polymorphism and Nicotine Dependence: an Evaluation of Nonreplicated Results
- 1 June 2005
- journal article
- Published by American Association for Cancer Research (AACR) in Cancer Epidemiology, Biomarkers & Prevention
- Vol. 14 (6) , 1384-1389
Abstract
Review articles have focused attention on and cited possible reasons for the nonreplication of genetic association studies. Herein, we illustrate how one might work through these possible reasons to make a judgment about the most plausible reason(s) when faced with two or more studies which yield seemingly inconsistent results. In the first study, 342 treatment-seeking smokers were genotyped for the Val108Met polymorphism in the functional catechol-O-methyl-transferase (COMT) locus. Alleles coding Val at codon 108 are denoted as H and those coding Met are denoted as L. An association between presence of the “H” (high activity) allele and pretreatment level of nicotine dependence level using the Fagerstrom Test for Nicotine Dependence was detected (P = 0.0072), after controlling for baseline body mass index (BMI, kg/m2), depression symptoms, and age. To validate this initial finding, 443 treatment-seeking smokers from an independent smoking cessation clinical trial were genotyped for the COMT polymorphism. Within the second study, no association between presence of the “H” allele and nicotine dependence was detected (P = 0.6418) after controlling for baseline BMI, depression symptoms, and age. We critically reviewed both studies with regard to often cited reasons for nonreplication, including type I error, population stratification, low statistical power, and imprecise measures of phenotype. Although in our opinion the failure to replicate the initial association in the second study is likely either the result of low statistical power to detect a small effect or effect heterogeneity, thorough analyses failed to definitively identify the reason for nonreplication.Keywords
This publication has 26 references indexed in Scilit:
- Control of Confounding of Genetic Associations in Stratified PopulationsThe American Journal of Human Genetics, 2003
- Maneuvering in the Complex Path from Genotype to PhenotypeScience, 2002
- Accounting for Unmeasured Population Substructure in Case-Control Studies of Genetic Association Using a Novel Latent-Class ModelThe American Journal of Human Genetics, 2001
- Use of Unlinked Genetic Markers to Detect Population Stratification in Association StudiesThe American Journal of Human Genetics, 1999
- Effects of nicotine on the nucleus accumbens and similarity to those of addictive drugsNature, 1996
- Human catechol-O-methyltransferase pharmacogenetics: description of a functional polymorphism and its potential application to neuropsychiatric disordersPharmacogenetics, 1996
- Kinetics of Human Soluble and Membrane-Bound Catechol O-Methyltransferase: A Revised Mechanism and Description of the Thermolabile Variant of the EnzymeBiochemistry, 1995
- Computing Confidence Bounds for Power and Sample Size of the General Linear Univariate ModelThe American Statistician, 1995
- The Fagerström Test for Nicotine Dependence: a revision of the Fagerstrom Tolerance QuestionnaireBritish Journal of Addiction, 1991
- The CES-D ScaleApplied Psychological Measurement, 1977