Militantly ‘studying up’? (Ab)using whiteness for oppositional research
Author:
Abstract
This paper develops the idea of militantly ‘studying up’. Through a discussion of research into the relationship between migrants and social/labour movements in Buenos Aires, Argentina, it explores the way in which my positionality both helped and hindered the (militant) research process. As the possibility for militant research seemed to recede, by interrogating the antagonisms bound up in the disjuncture between my perceived and my performed positionality, I was able to retain a commitment to militant research/research militancy. The movement to a form of oppositional (auto)ethnography was underpinned by an (ab)use of my whiteness. This touched on new possibilities for militant research, and also afforded further reflection on the structuring power of whiteness itself. Situating itself against‐and‐beyond discussions of militant research, this paper explores not only the rich potential but also the difficulties and limitations of such a methodology. In this regard it foregrounds discussion of failure as a key reflexive strategy. Ultimately it argues that there is potentially value in ‘studying up’ within militant (migration) research, but that concerns surround the (re‐)reification of the very identities and structures that are intended to be deconstructed.Keywords
This publication has 33 references indexed in Scilit:
- The head vs. the gut: Emotions, positionality, and the challenges of fieldwork with a Southern nationalist movementGeoforum, 2010
- Interviewing landed elites in post-war GuatemalaGeoforum, 2010
- Personality: a new positionality?Area, 2008
- Critical Whiteness StudiesSociology Compass, 2007
- Analytic AutoethnographyJournal of Contemporary Ethnography, 2006
- After race: Ethnography, race and post-race theoryEthnic and Racial Studies, 2006
- Travelling East as Walter Kurtz: Identity, Performance, and Collaboration in Goa, IndiaEnvironment and Planning D: Society and Space, 2002
- Absence for Whom? An Autoethnography of White SubjectivityCultural Studies ↔ Critical Methodologies, 2001
- Against Reflexivity as an Academic Virtue and Source of Privileged KnowledgeTheory, Culture & Society, 2000
- Geography matters? Whiteness and contemporary geographyArea, 2000