This article revisits open innovation by conceptualizing ideas as evolving processes rather than knowledge flows. Building on the notion of “idea journeys,” we argue that the strategic value of openness depends not only on whether firms open their boundaries, but on when and where they engage with ideas along their development. We propose a phase-dependent framework that distinguishes three stages of the ideation process, emergence, cognitive construction, and implementation, and links them to outside-in, inside-out, and coupled open innovation strategies. Our analysis shows that each phase entails distinct strategic challenges and requires specific organizational and dynamic capabilities. Firms must develop the ability to sense and access emerging ideas, participate in their social construction through interactions with diverse actors, and reconfigure resources to implement, transfer, or scale ideas. We further show that the effectiveness of open innovation strategies depends on the alignment between these capabilities and the phase of the idea journey in which firms intervene. This perspective emphasizes that openness is inherently time-dependent and cannot be reduced to the management of knowledge inflows and outflows alone. By shifting attention from boundary permeability to the strategic orchestration of idea journeys, this study contributes to open innovation and strategy research by integrating a temporal and processual dimension into the analysis of openness. It also highlights key managerial challenges related to evaluating, timing, and coordinating openness decisions, offering a more nuanced understanding of how firms can align open innovation with their broader strategic objectives.