Repeatability and Inter-device Agreement for Three Different Methods of Keratometry: Placido, Scheimpflug, and Color LED Corneal Topography
- 1 March 2015
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SLACK, Inc. in Journal of Refractive Surgery
- Vol. 31 (3) , 176-181
Abstract
PURPOSE: To determine the repeatability of a color LED corneal topographer (Cassini; iOptics, The Hague, The Netherlands) and compare it with Placido and Scheimpflug based devices (EyeSys 2000; EyeSys Laboratories, Houston, TX, and Pentacam HR; Oculus Optikgeräte GmbH, Wetzlar, Germany). METHODS: This prospective study involved 20 healthy volunteers (20 eyes) recruited from the staff of the Antwerp University Hospital. For each eye, three measurements were taken using each device, from which eight parameters describing keratometry and astigmatism were derived. Repeatability was assessed using intrasession, within-subject analysis of variance. Agreement was evaluated between pairs of devices with Bland– Altman plots and 95% confidence intervals. RESULTS: The repeatability values were good for all three devices, although slightly worse for the Cassini than for the other two devices for steep, flat, and mean keratometry. The EyeSys showed worse repeatability for the astigmatism axis. EyeSys and Pentacam agreed well with each other in terms of mean keratometry, whereas the Cassini gave consistently higher values by 0.52 diopters (D) when compared with the EyeSys ( P < .05, paired t test) and by 0.38 D when compared with the Pentacam ( P < .05, paired t test). The Cassini provided similar repeatability values (2.31°) for the astigmatism axis to the Pentacam (2.22°), in contrast to the EyeSys, which produced much more variable axes (9.0°) ( P < .05, paired t test). CONCLUSIONS: Overall, the three devices display comparable repeatability. The one exception is the astigmatism axis measurement of the EyeSys. The Cassini provides higher keratometry values than the other two devices, but the astigmatism axis agrees well with that provided by the Pentacam. [ J Refract Surg. 2015;31(3):176–181.]Keywords
This publication has 20 references indexed in Scilit:
- Forme Fruste Keratoconus Imaging and Validation via Novel Multi-Spot Reflection TopographyCase Reports in Ophthalmology, 2013
- Repeatability, reproducibility, and agreement of corneal power measurements obtained with a new corneal topographerJournal of Cataract & Refractive Surgery, 2013
- Comparison and Repeatability of Keratometric and Corneal Power Measurements Obtained by Orbscan II, Pentacam, and Galilei Corneal Tomography SystemsAmerican Journal of Ophthalmology, 2013
- A Comprehensive Assessment of the Precision and Agreement of Anterior Corneal Power Measurements Obtained Using 8 Different DevicesPLOS ONE, 2012
- Comparison of anterior segment measurements by 3 Scheimpflug tomographers and 1 Placido corneal topographerJournal of Cataract & Refractive Surgery, 2011
- A Comprehensive Evaluation of the Precision (Repeatability and Reproducibility) of the Oculus Pentacam HRInvestigative Ophthalmology & Visual Science, 2011
- Interchangeability between Placido disc and Scheimpflug system: quantitative and qualitative analysisArquivos Brasileiros de Oftalmologia, 2010
- Agreement Between Pentacam and Videokeratography in Corneal Power AssessmentJournal of Refractive Surgery, 2009
- Corneal topography with Scheimpflug imaging and videokeratography: Comparative study of normal eyesJournal of Cataract & Refractive Surgery, 2009
- Biometry and intraocular lens power calculationCurrent Opinion in Ophthalmology, 2008