Library preparation strategy critically impacts RNA virus sensitivity in clinical metagenomics
Authors:
- Bede ConstantinidesBCBede Constantinides
- Mia WeaverMWMia Weaver
- Samantha TreagusSTSamantha Treagus
- Sam Aj WilkinsonSWSam Aj Wilkinson
- Samuel QuartonSQSamuel Quarton
- Mahboobeh BehruzniaMBMahboobeh Behruznia
- Nicola CumleyNCNicola Cumley
- Alan McNallyAMAlan McNally
- Nicholas James LomanNLNicholas James Loman
- Steven PullanSPSteven Pullan
Preprint
Abstract
Clinical metagenomics uses sequencing for culture-independent identification of pathogens directly from clinical specimens. While a number of protocols claim to be pathogen agnostic, sensitivity for RNA viruses is likely lower than for bacteria or fungi, as it requires additional processing steps including conversion to cDNA. Sequence-independent, single-primer amplification (SISPA) was first described in 1991, yet how it preferentially enriches viral molecules has never been described. Here we propose that single-primer amplification exploits the PCR suppression effect, which selectively amplifies longer viral molecules over shorter host-derived cDNA fragments on the basis of size. This model predicts that any upstream processing step that disrupts fragment length will prevent this enrichment occurring. To test this, we systematically compared two adapter introduction strategies - during cDNA synthesis and via tagmentation - followed by single primer amplification, using the ZeptoMetrix Respiratory Panel 2.1 containing 16 RNA and 3 DNA virus strains. SISPA-based approaches recovered all of the viral genomes in the control, whereas using tagmentation to amplify cDNA recovered none. We then spiked the controls into extracted clinical samples and found that SISPA-based methods performed best in all background settings, however in high-background settings no viral genomes were recovered by any approach. Finally, using a modified SMART-9N protocol, we demonstrated that single-primer PCR is critical to overall performance, indicating that direct tagmentation of cDNA and dual-primer PCR should be avoided in protocols for clinical metagenomics where high sensitivity for RNA viruses is critical. These findings demonstrate that library preparation strategy fundamentally determines RNA virus sensitivity and offer mechanistic insights for protocol optimisation with direct relevance to clinical metagenomics.Keywords
This publication has 38 references indexed in Scilit:
- Untargeted metagenomics protocol for the diagnosis of infection from CSF and tissue from sterile sitesHeliyon, 2023
- Nanopore metagenomic sequencing to investigate nosocomial transmission of human metapneumovirus from a unique genetic group among haematology patients in the United KingdomJournal of Infection, 2020
- Nanopore metagenomics enables rapid clinical diagnosis of bacterial lower respiratory infectionNature Biotechnology, 2019
- Viral Concentration and Amplification from Human Serum Samples Prior to Application of Next-Generation Sequencing Analysis2018
- Virome Sequencing of Stool Samples2018
- Unbiased metagenomic sequencing complements specific routine diagnostic methods and increases chances to detect rare viral strainsDiagnostic Microbiology and Infectious Disease, 2015
- SISPA-Seq for rapid whole genome surveys of bacterial isolatesInfection, Genetics and Evolution, 2015
- PCR-suppression effect: Kinetic analysis and application to representative or long-molecule biased PCR-based amplification of complex samplesJournal of Biotechnology, 2007
- A method for the rapid sequence-independent amplification of microdissected chromosomal materialGenomics, 1992
- Sequence-independent, single-primer amplification (SISPA) of complex DNA populationsMolecular and Cellular Probes, 1991