The Economic Feasibility of (Re-)Introducing Tram-Trains in Canada: Okanagan Valley Electric Regional Passenger Rail
Open Access
- 13 May 2024
- journal article
- research article
- Published by MDPI AG in Sustainability
- Vol. 16 (10) , 4081
Abstract
Population and tourism growth has increased congestion, collisions, climate harming emissions, and transport inequities in the Okanagan Valley, British Columbia (B.C.), Canada. Surveys indicate a willingness among residents to switch from cars to public transit featuring better service levels and connections. We conducted an analysis on the economic feasibility of an Okanagan Valley Electric Regional Passenger Rail (OVER PR) powered by zero-emission (ZE) Fuel Cell/Battery Hybrid Rail (Hydrail) technology along a 342-km route between Osoyoos, B.C., at the US Border and Kamloops, B.C., the Canadian VIA rail hub. Hydrail passenger light-rail has operated successfully since 2018 in Germany and was demonstrated in Quebec, Canada, in 2023. Technical analyses have confirmed the feasibility in B.C. on steep Highway (Hwy) 97 grades and mountainous weather, with mode shift forecasts in the range of 30%. OVER PR economic analyses were also favorable, with net present value (NPV) = CAD 40 billion (CDN, base year 2023), benefit–cost ratio (BCR) = 9:1, and Return on Investments (IRR) = 33% over 30 years. Subject to additional stakeholder consultations and final design reviews, these results were tested against risks using Monte Carlo Simulation (MCS) and Reference-Class Forecasting (RCF), including worst-case risks such as 70% cost over-runs. OVER PR promises an economic transition to clean energy, sustainable transportation, and more livable communities, benefiting all Valley communities through greater transportation equity.Keywords
Funding Information
- Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council of Canada (2022-03056, 531564021, ALLRP 561186-20—UBC, 0825373)
- NSERC Undergraduate Student Research Grant (2022-03056, 531564021, ALLRP 561186-20—UBC, 0825373)
- NSERC Alliance Grant (2022-03056, 531564021, ALLRP 561186-20—UBC, 0825373)
- UBC Okanagan Work Study Grant (2022-03056, 531564021, ALLRP 561186-20—UBC, 0825373)
This publication has 11 references indexed in Scilit:
- Technical Feasibility of a Hydrail Tram–Train in NA: Okanagan Valley Electric Regional Passenger Rail (OVER PR)Sustainability, 2024
- Applying cost–benefit analysis to the economic evaluation of a tram-train system: Evidence from Brescia (Italy)Research in Transportation Business & Management, 2022
- The complex nature of transportation as a key determinant of health in primary and community care restructuring initiatives in rural CanadaJournal of Aging Studies, 2022
- Sustainability of hydrogen refuelling stations for trains using electrolysersInternational Journal of Hydrogen Energy, 2021
- How Does High-Speed Rail Affect Tourism? A Case Study of the Capital Region of ChinaSustainability, 2019
- Energy consumption and carbon dioxide emissions analysis for a concept design of a hydrogen hybrid railway vehicleIET Electrical Systems in Transportation, 2018
- High speed rail effects on tourism: Spanish empirical evidence derived from China's modelling experienceJournal of Transport Geography, 2016
- The feasibility of introducing light rail systems in medium-sized towns in Central EuropeJournal of Transport Geography, 2016
- Dynamic behavior of an embedded rail track coupled with a tram vehicleJournal of Vibration and Control, 2015
- Bus or Rail: An Approach to Explain the Psychological Rail FactorJournal of Public Transportation, 2012