Cross-platform nanopore benchmarking reveals methylation-associated substitution errors in bacterial reads
Preprint
Abstract
Nanopore sequencing enables long-read genome assembly and direct detection of DNA modifications, but emerging platforms require systematic evaluation against established technologies. We benchmarked CycloneSEQ against Oxford Nanopore Technologies R9.4.1 and R10.4.1 using matched native whole-genome sequencing and methylation-free whole-genome amplification libraries from six bacterial species. Updated CycloneSEQ chemistry and basecalling improved mean observed read accuracy to 96.0%, approaching R10.4.1. Across platforms, error spectra were non-random, with adenine-to-guanine and guanine-to-adenine substitutions consistently overrepresented. Comparisons with methylation-free controls showed that bacterial DNA methylation contributes substantially to these substitution patterns, highlighting a source of systematic nanopore error relevant to variant analysis. CycloneSEQ reads, when combined with short-read polishing, produced near-finished bacterial assemblies. We further show that CycloneSEQ supports bacterial methylation profiling: strand-specific basecalling errors enabled de novo discovery of 12 methylation-associated motifs, and two signal-to-reference alignment strategies enabled raw-signal comparison between native and amplification-derived reads. These results establish a cross-platform framework for nanopore benchmarking and extend bacterial epigenomic analysis to CycloneSEQ.Keywords
Funding Information
- Research Grants Council of the Hong Kong Special Administrative Region, China (Early Career Scheme (CityU 21100521))
- Research Grants Council of the Hong Kong Special Administrative Region, China (General Research Fund (11105524))
- Hong Kong Health and Medical Research Fund (08194126)
- City University of Hong Kong (9610497)
- City University of Hong Kong (9683001)
This publication has 40 references indexed in Scilit:
- Enhanced detection of RNA modifications in Escherichia coli utilizing direct RNA sequencingCell Reports Methods, 2025
- Comprehensive comparison of the third-generation sequencing tools for bacterial 6mA profilingNature Communications, 2025
- Giraffe: A tool for comprehensive processing and visualization of multiple long-read sequencing dataComputational and Structural Biotechnology Journal, 2024
- Comprehensive genomic and plasmid characterization of multidrug-resistant bacterial strains by R10.4.1 nanopore sequencingMicrobiological Research, 2024
- A signal processing and deep learning framework for methylation detection using Oxford Nanopore sequencingNature Communications, 2024
- Benchmarking of Nanopore R10.4 and R9.4.1 flow cells in single-cell whole-genome amplification and whole-genome shotgun sequencingComputational and Structural Biotechnology Journal, 2023
- Discovering multiple types of DNA methylation from bacteria and microbiome using nanopore sequencingNature Methods, 2021
- A conjugative plasmid that augments virulence in Klebsiella pneumoniaeNature Microbiology, 2019
- Assembly of long, error-prone reads using repeat graphsNature Biotechnology, 2019
- Detecting DNA cytosine methylation using nanopore sequencingNature Methods, 2017