Evaluating methods for the analysis of rare variants in sequence data
Open Access
- 29 November 2011
- journal article
- Published by Springer Nature in BMC Proceedings
- Vol. 5 (S9) , S119
Abstract
A number of rare variant statistical methods have been proposed for analysis of the impending wave of next-generation sequencing data. To date, there are few direct comparisons of these methods on real sequence data. Furthermore, there is a strong need for practical advice on the proper analytic strategies for rare variant analysis. We compare four recently proposed rare variant methods (combined multivariate and collapsing, weighted sum, proportion regression, and cumulative minor allele test) on simulated phenotype and next-generation sequencing data as part of Genetic Analysis Workshop 17. Overall, we find that all analyzed methods have serious practical limitations on identifying causal genes. Specifically, no method has more than a 5% true discovery rate (percentage of truly causal genes among all those identified as significantly associated with the phenotype). Further exploration shows that all methods suffer from inflated false-positive error rates (chance that a noncausal gene will be identified as associated with the phenotype) because of population stratification and gametic phase disequilibrium between noncausal SNPs and causal SNPs. Furthermore, observed true-positive rates (chance that a truly causal gene will be identified as significantly associated with the phenotype) for each of the four methods was very low (<19%). The combination of larger than anticipated false-positive rates, low true-positive rates, and only about 1% of all genes being causal yields poor discriminatory ability for all four methods. Gametic phase disequilibrium and population stratification are important areas for further research in the analysis of rare variant data.Keywords
This publication has 8 references indexed in Scilit:
- Genetic Analysis Workshop 17 mini-exome simulationBMC Proceedings, 2011
- Health financing in Africa: overview of a dialogue among high level policy makersBMC Proceedings, 2011
- Statistical analysis of rare sequence variants: an overview of collapsing methodsGenetic Epidemiology, 2011
- Extending Rare-Variant Testing Strategies: Analysis of Noncoding Sequence and Imputed GenotypesThe American Journal of Human Genetics, 2010
- An evaluation of statistical approaches to rare variant analysis in genetic association studiesGenetic Epidemiology, 2009
- A Groupwise Association Test for Rare Mutations Using a Weighted Sum StatisticPLOS Genetics, 2009
- Methods for Detecting Associations with Rare Variants for Common Diseases: Application to Analysis of Sequence DataThe American Journal of Human Genetics, 2008
- On measures of gametic disequilibrium.Genetics, 1988