eDNA provides accurate population abundance estimates with bioenergetics and particle mass-balance modelling
Preprint
Abstract
Anthropogenic activities have led to an unprecedented crisis in freshwater biodiversity loss. The capacity to monitor the abundance of wild populations is critical to conserving biodiversity, but conventional physical specimen collection methods are invasive, costly, and labour-intensive. Environmental DNA (eDNA) offers a promising alternative, being easy to sample, with studies under controlled laboratory conditions showing consistent correlations between eDNA concentration and abundance. However, applying eDNA to monitor abundance remains contentious, as eDNA particle dynamics and the ecology of eDNA production can decouple this relationship in natural ecosystems. To address this, we integrated bioenergetics and mass-balance frameworks to relate eDNA concentrations to freshwater fish population abundance estimated through conventional mark-recapture in Brook Trout (Salvelinus fontinalis) across nine Rocky Mountains lakes, five of which underwent size-selectively harvest over two years. Our integrated framework improved the variance explained in eDNA concentrations from 24% to 71%. The integrated model accurately distinguished most abundance estimates across populations and sampling periods, detecting both natural and harvest-induced reductions in abundance within several populations. This study is the first to empirically integrate the DNA production ecology and particle dynamics, demonstrating that properly accounting for ‘the ecology of eDNA’ enables rapid, accurate abundance quantification. We also discuss future research and applications of eDNA in light of these results. Significance statement Addressing the unprecedented freshwater biodiversity crisis requires cost- and time-effective methods for estimating abundance and biomass. Our study empirically demonstrates the potential of eDNA for rapid and accurate assessment of abundance in natural populations by integrating hydrology, chemistry and bioenergetics into a mass-balance modelling framework. Through a replicated whole-ecosystem experiment, we show that eDNA not only detects differences in fish abundance and biomass across populations, but also captures natural and experimentally induced abundance changes within populations. Our modeling approach enables eDNA to generate abundance and biomass estimates comparable in precision and accuracy to high-quality mark-recapture methods.Keywords
All Related Versions
- Published version: Molecular Ecology, 35 (7), e70329.
Funding Information
- Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council of Canada
This publication has 67 references indexed in Scilit:
- Interspecific allometric scaling in eDNA production among northwestern Atlantic bony fishes reflects physiological allometric scalingEnvironmental DNA, 2022
- Effect of biotic and abiotic factors on the production and degradation of fish environmental DNA: An experimental evaluationEnvironmental DNA, 2021
- Vertical stratification of environmental DNA in the open ocean captures ecological patterns and behavior of deep‐sea fishesLimnology and Oceanography Letters, 2021
- Degradation modeling of water environmental DNA: Experiments on multiple DNA sources in pond and seawaterEnvironmental DNA, 2021
- Environmental DNA (eDNA) as a tool for assessing fish biomass: A review of approaches and future considerations for resource surveysEnvironmental DNA, 2021
- Allometric scaling of eDNA production in stream‐dwelling brook trout (Salvelinus fontinalis) inferred from population size structureEnvironmental DNA, 2020
- Meta‐analysis supports further refinement of eDNA for monitoring aquatic species‐specific abundance in natureEnvironmental DNA, 2019
- Understanding the effects of biotic and abiotic factors on sources of aquatic environmental DNABiodiversity and Conservation, 2019
- Effect of water temperature and fish biomass on environmental DNA shedding, degradation, and size distributionEcology and Evolution, 2019
- Predicting nutrient excretion of aquatic animals with metabolic ecology and ecological stoichiometry: a global synthesisEcology, 2016