Comparative Study of the Main Top-down Approaches for the Estimation of Measurement Uncertainty in Multiresidue Analysis of Pesticides in Fruits and Vegetables
- 14 December 2010
- journal article
- research article
- Published by American Chemical Society (ACS) in Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry
- Vol. 59 (14) , 7609-7619
Abstract
Practical “top-down” approaches appear to be the most suitable for the evaluation of measurement uncertainty in pesticide residue testing laboratories, where analytical procedures are routinely applied to a large number of pesticide/food combinations. The opposite approach, “bottom-up” evaluation of measurement uncertainty, leads to great difficulties in evaluating all of the pesticides in a consistent way. Among the top-down approaches, there are two main ways in which measurement uncertainty can be estimated: One is based on default values, which are based on previous extensive interlaboratory experience and the proven accuracy of the laboratory; these include the Horwitz equation or the fit-for-purpose relative standard deviation (FFP-RSD). The other is based on experimental data from the quality control work of the laboratory: within-laboratory reproducibility, interlaboratory validation, or a combination of results obtained in proficiency tests. The principal existing guidelines from various bodies (Eurachem, Nordtest, and Eurolab) all propose different approaches for calculating measurement uncertainty. In this paper, the main top-down approaches are evaluated and compared using the data from the European Proficiency Test Database for Fruits and Vegetables and the Multiresidue Method validation databases obtained from the National Reference and Official Laboratories in Europe. The main conclusion of the comparative study is that a default expanded measurement uncertainty value of 50% could satisfy all of the requirements for facilitating and harmonizing, worldwide, the intercomparability of the pesticide residue confidence results between laboratories.Keywords
This publication has 18 references indexed in Scilit:
- Comparison of QuEChERS sample preparation methods for the analysis of pesticide residues in fruits and vegetablesJournal of Chromatography A, 2010
- Estimating uncertainty in analytical procedures based on chromatographic techniquesJournal of Chromatography A, 2010
- Validation and uncertainty study of a comprehensive list of 160 pesticide residues in multi-class vegetables by liquid chromatography–tandem mass spectrometryJournal of Chromatography A, 2008
- Analysis of pesticide residues in fruit and vegetables with ethyl acetate extraction using gas and liquid chromatography with tandem mass spectrometric detectionAnalytical and Bioanalytical Chemistry, 2007
- Uncertainty associated to the analysis of organochlorine pesticides in water by solid-phase microextraction/gas chromatography–electron capture detection—Evaluation using two different approachesAnalytica Chimica Acta, 2006
- Estimation of variance components with high breakdown point and high efficiencyBiometrika, 2001
- Recent trends in inter-laboratory precision at ppb and sub-ppb concentrations in relation to fitness for purpose criteria in proficiency testingThe Analyst, 2000
- A Horwitz-like function describes precision in a proficiency testThe Analyst, 1995
- Comparison of the efficiency of different GLC multi-residue methods on crops containing pesticide residuesAnalytical and Bioanalytical Chemistry, 1991
- Evaluation of analytical methods used for regulation of foods and drugsAnalytical Chemistry, 1982