Interpreting personalization in England's National Health Service: a textual analysis
- 18 December 2009
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Critical Policy Studies
- Vol. 3 (2) , 204-220
Abstract
Different versions of choice are at work in England's National Health Service. A hard version of choice associated with provider competition (and patient exit) appears to be giving way to a ‘softer’ concept of ‘personalization’, emphasizing choice and voice at the micro level, but also drawing on solidaristic themes. As personalization becomes increasingly central to health reform, it is important to interpret the ways in which a personalization narrative is being used. It is also necessary to trace its ambivalent framing of National Health Service patients, staff and structures. This paper uses textual analysis to explore how personalization has been positioned in ministerial speeches and health policy documents. It finds that personalization is located in a discourse of organizational decline and disruption, emphasizing the need for patient exit and voice as recuperative mechanisms, but also one of consolidation, trust and equity, emphasizing loyalty to shared welfare services. Hirschman makes clear that an interplay between exit, voice and loyalty is to be expected. However, there is an ambivalence in their relationship which is being ignored by health policy-makers. Frontline staff and service users are left to negotiate an agenda which positions them as both partners and adversaries.Keywords
This publication has 33 references indexed in Scilit:
- Personalization and de-schooling: Uncommon trajectories in contemporary education policyCritical Social Policy, 2009
- The NHS after 10 years of New Labour2008
- Choice and Voice – A ReviewSocial Policy and Society, 2008
- Realising the Potential of Co-production: Negotiating Improvements in Public ServicesSocial Policy and Society, 2008
- A NEW EPOCH OF INDIVIDUALIZATION? PROBLEMS WITH THE ‘PERSONALIZATION’ OF PUBLIC SECTOR SERVICESPublic Administration, 2007
- Increasing User Choice or Privatizing Risk? The Antinomies of PersonalizationThe British Journal of Social Work, 2007
- CENTRAL REGULATION OF ENGLISH LOCAL AUTHORITIES: AN EXAMPLE OF META‐GOVERNANCE?Public Administration, 2006
- POLICY AS NARRATIVE: NEW LABOUR’S REFORM OF THE NATIONAL HEALTH SERVICEPublic Administration, 2006
- Social Inequality under a New Social Contract: Long‐term Care in JapanSocial Policy & Administration, 2003
- What's New about ‘New Labour’?Politics, 2001