Prioritizing registered donors in organ allocation
Authors:
- Jacob LaveeJLJacob Lavee
- Dan W. BrockDBDan W. Brock
- 1 December 2012
- journal article
- review article
- Published by Wolters Kluwer Health in Current Opinion in Critical Care
- Vol. 18 (6) , 707-711
Abstract
A new organ transplant law in Israel, which gives priority in organ allocation to candidates who in various ways support organ donation, has resulted in a significant increase in organ donation in 2011. We provide an ethical analysis of the new law. We note that by continuing to require opt-in consent, the Israeli law has an ethical advantage over opt-out laws, which may result in some use of organs from donors who have not consented. We discuss the fair response to 'free-riding' candidates who, usually for religious reasons, are opposed to donation, but nevertheless seek a transplant, who will not receive any priority over candidates who have been registered donors for at least 3 years before listing. We spell out several reasons why it is potentially unfair to prioritize patients whose first-degree relatives are registered donors, whereas it is fair to prioritize candidates who have been living directed or nondirected donors. Finally, we note the difficulty of ensuring public awareness of the priority system, which is necessary for its fairness. Athough needing some modifications, the new Israeli law is based on sound ethical approach that seems to begin already to bear fruits.Keywords
This publication has 13 references indexed in Scilit:
- Organ Donation and Priority Points in IsraelTransplantation, 2012
- Opt-in or opt-out for organ transplantationCurrent Opinion in Anaesthesiology, 2012
- Potential Limitations of Presumed Consent LegislationTransplantation, 2012
- The authority of next-of-kin in explicit and presumed consent systems for deceased organ donation: an analysis of 54 nationsNephrology Dialysis Transplantation, 2011
- Opt-out organ donation without presumptionsJournal of Medical Ethics, 2011
- The Practical, Moral, and Ethical Considerations of the New Israeli Law for the Allocation of Donor OrgansTransplantation Proceedings, 2010
- Informing the Debate: Rates of Kidney Transplantation in Nations With Presumed ConsentAnnals of Internal Medicine, 2010
- A new law for allocation of donor organs in IsraelThe Lancet, 2010
- Free riding and organ donationJournal of Medical Ethics, 2009
- The Evolution of Reciprocal AltruismThe Quarterly Review of Biology, 1971