Multivocal accountability in grand challenges: the Italian government’s response to COVID-19 between science and politics
Open Access
- 11 September 2025
- journal article
- Published by Emerald Publishing in Accounting, Auditing & Accountability Journal
- Vol. 38 (7) , 1919-1945
Abstract
Purpose: This paper investigates the multivocal nature of accountability in the context of grand challenges (GCs) by examining how diverse perspectives from science and politics combined and shaped the justifications provided by the Italian government in its response to the COVID-19 crisis. Design/methodology/approach: Drawing on Latour’s concepts of purification and mediation as processes to frame, separate or negotiate between science and politics, we thematically analyse the Italian government’s press conference transcripts and official public documents. This analysis enables us to identify the patterns of purification and mediation through which accountability was discharged and evolved over 15 months through the pandemic challenge. Findings: Our findings reveal how processes of purification and mediation of scientific and political aspects of the COVID-19 response contributed to the construction of a multivocal form of accountability by the Italian government. The processes are found to support the continuous redefinition and repositioning of multifaceted interpretations that are necessary when responding to a highly complex challenge such as COVID-19 pandemic. Practical implications: In making tough decisions in the context of GCs and crises, governments must continuously strike a balance between scientific evidence and political and societal concerns. A multivocal approach to accountability is invoked to mediate among multiple considerations from scientific communities, politicians and citizens. Originality/value: This work contributes to accountability research by adopting the concept of multivocality to characterise the adaptive and multi-dimensional nature of accountability in the context of GCs, where science and politics continuously intertwine.Keywords
This publication has 54 references indexed in Scilit:
- The translation of an extraordinary event and the role of accounts: The covid-19 caseCritical Perspectives on Accounting, 2024
- The blind spots of interdisciplinarity in addressing grand challengesCritical Perspectives on Accounting, 2022
- The governmentality of corporate (un)sustainability: the case of the ILVA steel plant in Taranto (Italy)Journal of Management and Governance, 2019
- Earthquakes, exceptional government and extraordinary accountingAccounting, Organizations and Society, 2015
- The socializing effects of accounting in flood recoveryCritical Perspectives on Accounting, 2014
- Breakdowns of accountability in the face of natural disasters: The case of Hurricane KatrinaCritical Perspectives on Accounting, 2014
- Downward accountability for a natural disaster recovery effort: Evidence and issues from Australia's Black SaturdayCritical Perspectives on Accounting, 2014
- Consultancy outputs and the purification of accounting technologiesAccounting, Organizations and Society, 2010
- The chameleon of accountability: Forms and discoursesAccounting, Organizations and Society, 1995
- The aura of accounting in the context of a crisis: Germany and the first world warAccounting, Organizations and Society, 1991