Responsibility gaps in closed-loop and adaptive neuromodulation: a distributed-control framework and its tests
Open Access
- 16 October 2026
- journal article
- Published by Editorial JOGB in NeuroData
- Vol. 3
Abstract
Adaptive and closed-loop neuromodulation devices change their own stimulation parameters and thereby shape mood, motivation and behaviour, but the frameworks used to assign responsibility for their harms were built for open-loop devices and for disembodied algorithms. The responsibility-gap thesis holds that no human satisfies the conditions of responsibility when a learning system acts in ways nobody specified; closed-loop brain stimulation makes that problem acute because the device partly constitutes the very agency that would be judged. A distributed-control framework is developed that places responsibility across four loci, the user, the clinician, the manufacturer and the algorithm, and predicts that gaps open where parameter changes outpace a person's capacity to understand or veto them and close where the device keeps its state legible and preserves a veto. Evidence from patient cohorts and experimental vignettes falsifies the naive prediction that more autonomy means more disruption: open-loop cohorts report more relational disturbance than adaptive ones, which motivates the legibility-and-veto extension. The framework is then translated into research questions for device design, tort and criminal law, and clinical consent.This publication has 126 references indexed in Scilit:
- Identity Theft, Deep Brain Stimulation, and the Primacy of Post‐trial ObligationsHastings Center Report, 2024
- Adaptive Deep Brain Stimulation: From Experimental Evidence Toward Practical ImplementationMovement Disorders, 2023
- Reasons for Meaningful Human ControlEthics and Information Technology, 2022
- Artificial intelligence and responsibility gaps: what is the problem?Ethics and Information Technology, 2022
- The Moral Responsibility Gap and the Increasing Autonomy of Systems2018
- Brainjacking in deep brain stimulation and autonomyEthics and Information Technology, 2018
- Robots, law and the retribution gapEthics and Information Technology, 2016
- Adaptive deep brain stimulation in advanced Parkinson diseaseAnnals of Neurology, 2013
- Computer systems: Moral entities but not moral agentsEthics and Information Technology, 2006
- The responsibility gap: Ascribing responsibility for the actions of learning automataEthics and Information Technology, 2004