Comparison of CATCH, PECARN and CHALICE rules in children with minor head trauma
- 15 April 2026
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in European Journal of Trauma and Emergency Surgery
- Vol. 52 (1) , 129
Abstract
Purpose The aim of this study is to prospectively compare the diagnostic performance of the PECARN, CATCH, and CHALICE clinical decision rules in pediatric patients presenting with minor head trauma, within a rural secondary-level emergency department characterized by limited resources, high patient volume, and restricted access to specialist physicians. Methods The study was designed as a prospective observational study. The PECARN, CATCH, and CHALICE clinical decision rules were applied to the patients included in the study, and the data were recorded. The data included in the study were statistically analyzed using the SPSS (Statistical Package for Social Sciences; SPSS Inc., Chicago, IL) 27 program. A value of p < 0.05 was considered statistically significant. Results A total of 1,032 patients were included in the study. The PECARN did not miss any of the 15 patients with pathological brain CT and had 100% sensitivity and 52.1% specificity. CATCH failed to detect pathological brain CT in 1 patient and had 93.3% sensitivity and 53.3% specificity. CHALICE failed to detect pathological brain CT in 2 patients, with 86.7% sensitivity and 87.8% specificity. Overall, PECARN was more successful in detecting pathological brain CT, but it also had a high false-positive brain CT rate. Conclusion PECARN criteria are more sensitive than other criteria in predicting brain CT pathology, but they lead to a large number of brain CT scans. While the CHALICE criteria are beneficial in reducing unnecessary brain CT scans, they may miss positive cases.Keywords
This publication has 17 references indexed in Scilit:
- Clinical predictors of abnormal brain computed tomography findings in mild traumatic brain injury: A cross-sectional studyMedicine, 2023
- Comparison of CATCH, PECARN, and CHALICE clinical decision rules in pediatric patients with mild head traumaEuropean Journal of Trauma and Emergency Surgery, 2022
- Validation of the PECARN head trauma prediction rules in Japan: A multicenter prospective studyThe American Journal of Emergency Medicine, 2020
- The Use of PECARN and CATCH Rules in Children With Minor Head Trauma Presenting to Emergency Department 24 Hours After InjuryPediatric Emergency Care, 2020
- A Cost-Effectiveness Analysis Comparing Clinical Decision Rules PECARN, CATCH, and CHALICE With Usual Care for the Management of Pediatric Head InjuryAnnals of Emergency Medicine, 2019
- Comparison of PECARN, CATCH, and CHALICE clinical decision rules for pediatric head injury in the emergency departmentCanadian Journal of Emergency Medicine, 2018
- Accuracy of Clinician Practice Compared With Three Head Injury Decision Rules in Children: A Prospective Cohort StudyAnnals of Emergency Medicine, 2018
- Accuracy of PECARN, CATCH, and CHALICE head injury decision rules in children: a prospective cohort studyThe Lancet, 2017
- Comparison of PECARN, CATCH, and CHALICE Rules for Children With Minor Head Injury: A Prospective Cohort StudyAnnals of Emergency Medicine, 2014
- Identification of children at very low risk of clinically-important brain injuries after head trauma: a prospective cohort studyThe Lancet, 2009