An empirics-first approach to problem formulation in service research: an illustration using the Cynefin framework
- 10 June 2026
- journal article
- Published by Emerald Publishing in Journal of Service Management
- p. 1-17
Abstract
Purpose: Although service research is an applied discipline, much of the field has emphasized confirmatory inquiry in relatively ordered settings. While such research remains valuable, it is often less well suited to emerging, relational and poorly understood service phenomena. This article therefore argues for an empirics-first approach to problem formulation in service research. Design/methodology/approach: Drawing on the Cynefin framework, the article distinguishes among clear, complicated, complex and chaotic service problems. Using a conceptual approach, it extends Cynefin to service research methodology by showing how different problem contexts call for different forms of theorizing, methodological fit and research design. Findings: The article shows that what constitutes a meaningful contribution in service research depends on the nature of the problem being studied. In relatively ordered contexts, contributions often involve refinement, replication and the specification of contingencies. In complicated contexts, they involve disentangling mechanisms and clarifying trade-offs. In complex contexts, contributions center on sensemaking and explaining emergent practices and processes. In chaotic contexts, contributions often lie in understanding stabilization, adaptation and the restoration of order under turbulent conditions. Originality/value: The article challenges service researchers to move beyond an overreliance on abstract literature gaps and theory-led confirmatory designs. Instead, it advocates careful empirical diagnosis of focal problems as the foundation for producing methodologically rigorous, theoretically meaningful and practically relevant research contributions.Keywords
This publication has 35 references indexed in Scilit:
- Luxury in the Circular Economy: An Engagement Journey PerspectiveJournal of Consumer Behaviour, 2025
- How can academics generate great research ideas? Inspiration from ideation practiceInternational Journal of Research in Marketing, 2023
- The managerial relevance of marketing science: Properties and genesisInternational Journal of Research in Marketing, 2023
- Exploring customer concerns on service quality under the COVID-19 crisis: A social media analytics study from the retail industryJournal of Retailing and Consumer Services, 2022
- Science is about corroborating empirical evidence, even in academic business research journalsJournal of Business Research, 2021
- A systems perspective on markets – Toward a research agendaJournal of Business Research, 2017
- Service-dominant logic 2025International Journal of Research in Marketing, 2017
- Institutions and axioms: an extension and update of service-dominant logicJournal of the Academy of Marketing Science, 2015
- Applying complexity theory to deepen service dominant logic: Configural analysis of customer experience-and-outcome assessments of professional services for personal transformationsJournal of Business Research, 2014
- Phenomenon-based Research in Management and Organisation Science: When is it Rigorous and Does it Matter?Long Range Planning, 2012