Randomized Controlled Trial Comparing Hand-Assisted Retroperitoneoscopic Versus Standard Laparoscopic Donor Nephrectomy
Authors:
- Leonienke F.C. DolsLDLeonienke F.C. Dols
- Niels F.M. KokNKNiels F.M. Kok
- Frank C.H. D’aNconaFDFrank C.H. D’aNcona
- Karel W.J. KlopKKKarel W.J. Klop
- T.C. Khe TranTTT.C. Khe Tran
- Johan F. LangenhuijsenJLJohan F. Langenhuijsen
- Türkan TerkivatanTTTürkan Terkivatan
- Frank J.M.F. DorFDFrank J.M.F. Dor
- Willem WeimarWWWillem Weimar
- Ine M. DooperIDIne M. Dooper
- Jan N.M. IjzermansJIJan N.M. Ijzermans
- 27 January 2014
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wolters Kluwer Health in Transplantation
- Vol. 97 (2) , 161-167
Abstract
Laparoscopic donor nephrectomy (LDN) has become the gold standard for live-donor nephrectomy, as it results in a short convalescence time and increased quality of life. However, intraoperative safety has been debated, as severe complications occur incidentally. Hand-assisted retroperitoneoscopic donor nephrectomy (HARP) is an alternative approach, combining the safety of hand-guided surgery with the benefits of endoscopic techniques and retroperitoneal access. We assessed the best approach to optimize donors' quality of life and safety. In two tertiary referral centers, donors undergoing left-sided nephrectomy were randomly assigned to HARP or LDN. Primary endpoint was physical function, one of the dimensions of the Short Form-36 questionnaire on quality of life, at 1 month postoperatively. Secondary endpoints included intraoperative events and operation times. Follow-up was 1 year. In total, 190 donors were randomized. Physical function at 1 month follow-up did not significantly differ between groups (estimated difference, 1.79; 95% confidence interval, -4.1 to 7.68; P=0.55). HARP resulted in significantly shorter skin-to-skin time (mean, 159 vs. 188 min; P<0.001), shorter warm ischemia time (2 vs. 5 min; P<0.001) and a lower intraoperative event rate (5% vs. 11%, P=0.117). Length of stay (both 3 days; P=0.135) and postoperative complication rate (8% vs. 8%; P=1.00) were not significantly different. Potential graft-related complications did not significantly differ (6% vs. 13%; P=0.137). Compared with LDN, left-sided HARP leads to similar quality of life, shorter operating time, and warm ischemia time. Therefore, we recommend HARP as a valuable alternative to the laparoscopic approach for left-sided donor nephrectomy.Keywords
This publication has 28 references indexed in Scilit:
- Long-Term Follow-up of a Randomized Trial Comparing Laparoscopic and Mini-Incision Open Live Donor NephrectomyAmerican Journal of Transplantation, 2010
- Randomized clinical trial of laparoscopic versus open donor nephrectomyBritish Journal of Surgery, 2010
- Long-Term Consequences of Kidney DonationNew England Journal of Medicine, 2009
- The Current Practice of Live Donor Nephrectomy in EuropeTransplantation, 2006
- Comparison of laparoscopic and mini incision open donor nephrectomy: single blind, randomised controlled clinical trialBMJ, 2006
- Postoperative Pain and Convalescence in Living Kidney Donors—Laparoscopic Versus Open Donor Nephrectomy: A Randomized StudyAmerican Journal of Transplantation, 2006
- Donor Nephrectomy: Mini-Incision Muscle-Splitting Open Approach versus LaparoscopyTransplantation, 2006
- Fatal and Nonfatal Hemorrhagic Complications of Living Kidney DonationAnnals of Surgery, 2006
- Laparoscopic versus Open Living-Donor Nephrectomy: Experiences from a Prospective, Randomized, Single-Center Study Focusing on Donor SafetyTransplantation, 2005
- NO EVIDENCE OF ACCELERATED LOSS OF KIDNEY FUNCTION IN LIVING KIDNEY DONORS: RESULTS FROM A CROSS-SECTIONAL FOLLOW-UP1Transplantation, 2001