Measurement of statistical evidence on an absolute scale following thermodynamic principles
Authors:
Open Access
- 5 March 2013
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in Theory in Biosciences
- Vol. 132 (3) , 181-194
Abstract
Statistical analysis is used throughout biomedical research and elsewhere to assess strength of evidence. We have previously argued that typical outcome statistics (including p values and maximum likelihood ratios) have poor measure-theoretic properties: they can erroneously indicate decreasing evidence as data supporting an hypothesis accumulate; and they are not amenable to calibration, necessary for meaningful comparison of evidence across different study designs, data types, and levels of analysis. We have also previously proposed that thermodynamic theory, which allowed for the first time derivation of an absolute measurement scale for temperature (T), could be used to derive an absolute scale for evidence (E). Here we present a novel thermodynamically based framework in which measurement of E on an absolute scale, for which “one degree” always means the same thing, becomes possible for the first time. The new framework invites us to think about statistical analyses in terms of the flow of (evidential) information, placing this work in the context of a growing literature on connections among physics, information theory, and statistics.Keywords
All Related Versions
This publication has 22 references indexed in Scilit:
- KELVIN: A Software Package for Rigorous Measurement of Statistical Evidence in Human GeneticsHuman Heredity, 2011
- Where’s the Evidence?Human Heredity, 2011
- Expected Monotonicity – A Desirable Property for Evidence Measures?Human Heredity, 2010
- Accumulating quantitative trait linkage evidence across multiple datasets using the posterior probability of linkageGenetic Epidemiology, 2006
- Thermometers: Something for Statistical Geneticists to Think aboutHuman Heredity, 2006
- Comparison of ‘Model-Free’ and ‘Model-Based’ Linkage Statistics in the Presence of Locus Heterogeneity: Single Data Set and Multiple Data Set ApplicationsHuman Heredity, 2001
- Principal Information Theoretic ApproachesJournal of the American Statistical Association, 2000
- Statistical Evidence: A Likelihood ParadigmJournal of the American Statistical Association, 1998
- Understanding ThermodynamicsJournal of Applied Mechanics, 1970
- Information Theory and Statistical MechanicsPhysical Review B, 1957