The opportunity for sexual selection: not mismeasured, just misunderstood
Open Access
- 2 June 2011
- journal article
- editorial
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Journal of Evolutionary Biology
- Vol. 24 (9) , 2064-2071
Abstract
Evolutionary biologists have developed several indices, such as selection gradients (β) and the opportunity for sexual selection (Is), to quantify the actual and/or potential strength of sexual selection acting in natural or experimental populations. In a recent paper, Klug et al. (J. Evol. Biol.23, 2010, 447) contend that selection gradients are the only legitimate metric for quantifying sexual selection. They argue that Is and similar mating-system-based metrics provide unpredictable results, which may be uncorrelated with selection acting on a trait, and should therefore be abandoned. We find this view short-sighted and argue that the choice of metric should be governed by the research question at hand. We describe insights that measures such as the opportunity for selection can provide and also argue that Klug et al. have overstated the problems with this approach while glossing over similar issues with the interpretation of selection gradients. While no metric perfectly characterizes sexual selection in all circumstances, thoughtful application of existing measures has been and continues to be informative in evolutionary studies.Keywords
This publication has 48 references indexed in Scilit:
- Bateman Gradients in Hermaphrodites: An Extended Approach to Quantify Sexual SelectionThe American Naturalist, 2010
- THE INTENSITY OF SEXUAL SELECTION PREDICTS WEAPON SIZE IN MALE BOVIDSEvolution, 2007
- Variable female preferences drive complex male displaysNature, 2004
- Sexual Selection1994
- Animal Mating Systems: A Synthesis Based on Selection TheoryThe American Naturalist, 1994
- Reversed sex roles and parental energy investment in zygotes of two pipefish (Syngnathidae) speciesMarine Ecology Progress Series, 1986
- On the Measurement of Natural and Sexual Selection: ApplicationsEvolution, 1984
- On the Measurement of Natural and Sexual Selection: TheoryEvolution, 1984
- Antlers, body size and breeding group size in the CervidaeNature, 1980
- Intra-sexual selection in DrosophilaHeredity, 1948