Comparative chronic toxicity of imidacloprid, clothianidin, and thiamethoxam toChironomus dilutusand estimation of toxic equivalency factors
- 22 June 2016
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry
- Vol. 36 (2) , 372-382
Abstract
Nontarget aquatic insects are susceptible to chronic neonicotinoid insecticide exposure during the early stages of development from repeated runoff events and prolonged persistence of these chemicals. Investigations on the chronic toxicity of neonicotinoids to aquatic invertebrates have been limited to a few species and under different laboratory conditions that often preclude direct comparisons of the relative toxicity of different compounds. In the present study, full life-cycle toxicity tests using Chironomus dilutus were performed to compare the toxicity of 3 commonly used neonicotinoids: imidacloprid, clothianidin, and thiamethoxam. Test conditions followed a static-renewal exposure protocol in which lethal and sublethal endpoints were assessed on days 14 and 40. Reduced emergence success, advanced emergence timing, and male-biased sex ratios were sensitive responses to low-level neonicotinoid exposure. The 14-d median lethal concentrations for imidacloprid, clothianidin, and thiamethoxam were 1.52 μg/L, 2.41 μg/L, and 23.60 μg/L, respectively. The 40-d median effect concentrations (emergence) for imidacloprid, clothianidin, and thiamethoxam were 0.39 μg/L, 0.28 μg/L, and 4.13 μg/L, respectively. Toxic equivalence relative to imidacloprid was estimated through a 3-point response average of equivalencies calculated at 20%, 50%, and 90% lethal and effect concentrations. Relative to imidacloprid (toxic equivalency factor [TEF] = 1.0), chronic (lethality) 14-d TEFs for clothianidin and thiamethoxam were 1.05 and 0.14, respectively, and chronic (emergence inhibition) 40-d TEFs were 1.62 and 0.11, respectively. These population-relevant endpoints and TEFs suggest that imidacloprid and clothianidin exert comparable chronic toxicity to C. dilutus, whereas thiamethoxam induced comparable effects only at concentrations an order of magnitude higher. However, the authors caution that under field conditions, thiamethoxam readily degrades to clothianidin, thereby likely enhancing toxicity. Environ Toxicol Chem 2017;36:372–382. © 2016 SETACKeywords
This publication has 50 references indexed in Scilit:
- Macroinvertebrate community response to repeated short-term pulses of the insecticide imidaclopridAquatic Toxicology, 2012
- Traits and stress: keys to identify community effects of low levels of toxicants in test systemsEcotoxicology, 2011
- Structural and functional responses of benthic invertebrates to imidacloprid in outdoor stream mesocosmsEnvironmental Pollution, 2009
- Applied aspects of neonicotinoid uses in crop protectionPest Management Science, 2008
- Comparison of a score-based approach with risk-based ranking of in-use agricultural pesticides in canada to aquatic receptorsIntegrated Environmental Assessment and Management, 2008
- Emergent body size of mayfly survivorsFreshwater Biology, 2007
- Comparative toxicity of four insecticides, including imidacloprid and tebufenozide, to four aquatic arthropodsEnvironmental Toxicology and Chemistry, 1997
- Chironomus tentanslife-cycle test: Design and evaluation for use in assessing toxicity of contaminated sedimentsEnvironmental Toxicology and Chemistry, 1997
- Evaluation of interstitial water as a route of exposure for ammonia in sediment tests with benthic macroinvertebratesEnvironmental Toxicology and Chemistry, 1996
- Sexual dimorphism in Chironomus riparius (meigen): Impact on interpretation of growth in whole-sediment toxicity testsEnvironmental Toxicology and Chemistry, 1994