Organizational-Professional Conflict in the Collegiate and Secondary School Practice Settings: A Sequential, Mixed-Methods Study
Open Access
- 1 November 2023
- journal article
- research article
- Published by National Athletic Trainers' Association in Journal of Athletic Training
- Vol. 58 (11-12) , 1010-1020
Abstract
Context: Athletic trainers (ATs) are employed in various settings, which may use 1 of 3 organizational infrastructure models: (1) the sport/athletic model, (2) the medical model, and (3) the academic model. These different settings and organizational infrastructure models may result in varying levels of organizational-professional conflict (OPC). However, how OPC may differ across infrastructure models and practice settings is not known. Objective: To examine the prevalence of OPC among ATs in various organizational infrastructures and explore ATs’ perceptions of OPC, including its precipitating and mitigating factors. Design: Sequential explanatory mixed-methods study with equal emphasis on quantitative and qualitative components. Setting: Collegiate and secondary school institutions. Patients or Other Participants: Five hundred ninety-four ATs from collegiate and secondary schools. Data Collection and Analysis: We conducted a national cross-sectional survey using a validated scale to assess OPC. We then followed the quantitative survey with individual interviews. Trustworthiness was established with multiple-analyst triangulation and peer debriefing. Results: Athletic trainers experienced low to moderate degrees of OPC with no differences across practice settings or infrastructure models. Poor communication, others’ unfamiliarity with the AT’s scope of practice, and lack of medical knowledge were precipitating factors for OPC. Organizational relationships founded on trust and respect for one another; administrative support in that ATs were listened to, decisions were endorsed, and appropriate resources provided; and autonomy given to the AT were key components to preventing OPC. Conclusions: Most ATs experienced primarily low to moderate OPC. However, OPC continues to permeate professional practice to some extent in collegiate and secondary school settings, regardless of the infrastructure model used. The findings of this study highlight the role of administrative support that allows for autonomous AT practice as well as effective communication that is direct, open, and professional to decrease OPC.Keywords
This publication has 13 references indexed in Scilit:
- Secondary School Athletic Trainers' Experiences With Organizational Conflict: A Comparison Across Employment ModelsJournal of Athletic Training, 2022
- Challenges for Newly Credentialed Athletic Trainers During Their Transition to PracticeJournal of Athletic Training, 2019
- Role Strain, Part 1: Experiences of Athletic Trainers Employed in the Professional Sports SettingJournal of Athletic Training, 2018
- Pressure on Sports Medicine Clinicians to Prematurely Return Collegiate Athletes to Play After ConcussionJournal of Athletic Training, 2015
- The Experiences of Female Athletic Trainers in the Role of the Head Athletic TrainerJournal of Athletic Training, 2015
- Inter-Association Consensus Statement on Best Practices for Sports Medicine Management for Secondary Schools and CollegesJournal of Athletic Training, 2014
- Retention and Attrition Factors for Female Certified Athletic Trainers in the National Collegiate Athletic Association Division I Football Bowl Subdivision SettingJournal of Athletic Training, 2010
- Professional Role Complexity and Job Satisfaction of Collegiate Certified Athletic TrainersJournal of Athletic Training, 2008
- A General Inductive Approach for Analyzing Qualitative Evaluation DataAmerican Journal of Evaluation, 2006
- An Examination of Role Strain for University Nurse Faculty and its Relation to Socialization Experiences and Personal CharacteristicsJournal Of Nursing Education, 1991