A systematic review of frameworks for the interrelationships of mental health evidence and policy in low- and middle-income countries
Open Access
- 22 August 2018
- journal article
- review article
- Published by Springer Nature in Health Research Policy and Systems
- Vol. 16 (1) , 85
Abstract
The interrelationships between research evidence and policy-making are complex. Different theoretical frameworks exist to explain general evidence–policy interactions. One largely unexplored element of these interrelationships is how evidence interrelates with, and influences, policy/political agenda-setting. This review aims to identify the elements and processes of theories, frameworks and models on interrelationships of research evidence and health policy-making, with a focus on actionability and agenda-setting in the context of mental health in low- and middle-income countries (LMICs). A systematic review of theories was conducted based on the BeHeMOTh search method, using a tested and refined search strategy. Nine electronic databases and other relevant sources were searched for peer-reviewed and grey literature. Two reviewers screened the abstracts, reviewed full-text articles, extracted data and performed quality assessments. Analysis was based on a thematic analysis. The included papers had to present an actionable theoretical framework/model on evidence and policy interrelationships, such as knowledge translation or evidence-based policy, specifically target the agenda-setting process, focus on mental health, be from LMICs and published in English. From 236 publications included in the full text analysis, no studies fully complied with our inclusion criteria. Widening the focus by leaving out ‘agenda-setting’, we included ten studies, four of which had unique conceptual frameworks focusing on mental health and LMICs but not agenda-setting. The four analysed frameworks confirmed research gaps from LMICs and mental health, and a lack of focus on agenda-setting. Frameworks and models from other health and policy areas provide interesting conceptual approaches and lessons with regards to agenda-setting. Our systematic review identified frameworks on evidence and policy interrelations that differ in their elements and processes. No framework fulfilled all inclusion criteria. Four actionable frameworks are applicable to mental health and LMICs, but none specifically target agenda-setting. We have identified agenda-setting as a research theory gap in the context of mental health knowledge translation in LMICs. Frameworks from other health/policy areas could offer lessons on agenda-setting and new approaches for creating policy impact for mental health and to tackle the translational gap in LMICs.Keywords
Funding Information
- Economic and Social Research Council (ES/J500057/1)
This publication has 126 references indexed in Scilit:
- Galvanizers, Guides, Champions, and Shields: The Many Ways That Policymakers Use Public Health ResearchersThe Milbank Quarterly, 2011
- A worked example of "best fit" framework synthesis: A systematic review of views concerning the taking of some potential chemopreventive agentsBMC Medical Research Methodology, 2011
- Increasing the priority of mental health in Africa: findings from qualitative research in Ghana, South Africa, Uganda and ZambiaHealth Policy and Planning, 2010
- Research and Advice Giving: A Functional View of Evidence‐Informed Policy Advice in a Canadian Ministry of HealthThe Milbank Quarterly, 2009
- Pathways to the Use of Health Services Research in PolicyHealth Services Research, 2009
- The terrain of health policy analysis in low and middle income countries: a review of published literature 1994-2007Health Policy and Planning, 2008
- Knowledge Transfer and Exchange: Review and Synthesis of the LiteratureThe Milbank Quarterly, 2007
- Research, policy and practice: why developing countries are differentJournal of International Development, 2005
- Examining the Role of Health Services Research in Public PolicymakingThe Milbank Quarterly, 2002
- The politics of health sector reform in developing countries: three cases of pharmaceutical policyHealth Policy, 1995