Risk and benefit for umbrella trials in oncology: a systematic review and meta-analysis
Open Access
- 8 July 2022
- journal article
- review article
- Published by Springer Nature in BMC Medicine
- Vol. 20 (1) , 1-16
Abstract
Background: Umbrella clinical trials in precision oncology are designed to tailor therapies to the specific genetic changes within a tumor. Little is known about the risk/benefit ratio for umbrella clinical trials. The aim of our systematic review with meta-analysis was to evaluate the efficacy and safety profiles in cancer umbrella trials testing targeted drugs or a combination of targeted therapy with chemotherapy. Methods: Our study was prospectively registered in PROSPERO (CRD42020171494). We searched Embase and PubMed for cancer umbrella trials testing targeted agents or a combination of targeted therapies with chemotherapy. We included solid tumor studies published between 1 January 2006 and 7 October 2019. We measured the risk using drug-related grade 3 or higher adverse events (AEs), and the benefit by objective response rate (ORR), progression-free survival (PFS), and overall survival (OS). When possible, data were meta-analyzed. Results: Of the 6207 records identified, we included 31 sub-trials or arms of nine umbrella trials (N = 1637). The pooled overall ORR was 17.7% (95% confidence interval [CI] 9.5–25.9). The ORR for targeted therapies in the experimental arms was significantly lower than the ORR for a combination of targeted therapy drugs with chemotherapy: 13.3% vs 39.0%; p = 0.005. The median PFS was 2.4 months (95% CI 1.9–2.9), and the median OS was 7.1 months (95% CI 6.1–8.4). The overall drug-related death rate (drug-related grade 5 AEs rate) was 0.8% (95% CI 0.3–1.4), and the average drug-related grade 3/4 AE rate per person was 0.45 (95% CI 0.40–0.50). Conclusions: Our findings suggest that, on average, one in five cancer patients in umbrella trials published between 1 January 2006 and 7 October 2019 responded to a given therapy, while one in 125 died due to drug toxicity. Our findings do not support the expectation of increased patient benefit in cancer umbrella trials. Further studies should investigate whether umbrella trial design and the precision oncology approach improve patient outcomes.Keywords
Funding Information
- Narodowe Centrum Nauki (UMO-2019/35/N/HS1/00178)
This publication has 74 references indexed in Scilit:
- The influential and inspirational Gianni Bonadonna's life commitment to evidence-based cancer medicineAnnals of Oncology, 2015
- Impact of Precision Medicine in Diverse Cancers: A Meta-Analysis of Phase II Clinical TrialsJournal of Clinical Oncology, 2015
- Comprehensive Biomarker Analysis and Final Efficacy Results of Sorafenib in the BATTLE TrialClinical Cancer Research, 2013
- Panitumumab and irinotecan versus irinotecan alone for patients with KRAS wild-type, fluorouracil-resistant advanced colorectal cancer (PICCOLO): a prospectively stratified randomised trialThe Lancet Oncology, 2013
- Clinical and Biomarker Outcomes of the Phase II Vandetanib Study from the BATTLE TrialJournal of Thoracic Oncology, 2013
- Clinical Outcomes and Biomarker Profiles of Elderly Pretreated NSCLC Patients from the BATTLE TrialJournal of Thoracic Oncology, 2012
- Progression-Free Survival: Meaningful or Simply Measurable?Journal of Clinical Oncology, 2012
- The BATTLE Trial: Personalizing Therapy for Lung CancerCancer Discovery, 2011
- Assessing research risks systematically: the net risks testJournal of Medical Ethics, 2007
- When are research risks reasonable in relation to anticipated benefits?Nature Medicine, 2004