Reimagining residency selection: a lottery among the qualified
- 22 January 2026
- journal article
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Academic Medicine
- Vol. 101 (3) , 255-263
Abstract
The residency selection process remains a significant barrier to the actualization of competency-based education across the continuum of medical education in North America. Current residency selection practices emphasize a narrow set of comparative achievements—standardized test performance, publication counts, and honor society memberships—within a norm-referenced system, which can divert attention from developing criterion-referenced competencies that indicate readiness to provide safe, high-quality care on day 1 of residency. In this manuscript, the authors argue that the residency selection process must change in order to facilitate a growth-oriented, competency-based undergraduate medical experience that ensures preparedness for residency training across all applicants to graduate medical education programs. The authors explore current issues in residency selection, particularly the use of current measures that are nonpredictive of future success, biased, and incentivize an achievement-oriented mindset. These measures focus students away from competency toward attaining a checklist of achievements such as honors society membership, research publications, and other merit badges that are far less relevant to patient care and residency preparedness, which is antithetical to a competency-based approach. The authors propose supplanting the current application review process with a modified lottery among students deemed on track to be qualified by their medical schools to begin residency based on competency-based criterion rather than normative measures. This lottery would be for interview positions and focus on aligning students geographically and from a shared interest perspective with programs where they would ideally thrive. These students would subsequently interview with residency programs as they normally would and enter the Match. The authors detail how a modified lottery would function, including allowance for student choices, enhanced equality, and attention to special circumstances such as couples matching and international medical graduates as well as presenting pitfalls to this approach.Keywords
This publication has 44 references indexed in Scilit:
- Evaluating the Impact of the Novel Geographic Preferences Section on Interview Rate and Residency Match OutcomesJournal of General Internal Medicine, 2023
- Educating for adaptive expertise: case examples along the medical education continuumAdvances in Health Sciences Education, 2022
- Values-Based Resident Selection in an Internal Medicine-Pediatrics Residency ProgramJournal of General Internal Medicine, 2022
- Stakeholder Perspectives on Standardizing the Residency Application and Interview ProcessesJournal of Surgical Education, 2021
- A National Mixed-Methods Evaluation of Preparedness for General Surgery Residency and the Association With Resident BurnoutJAMA Surgery, 2020
- Improving the Residency Application and Selection ProcessJAMA, 2020
- Developing an Entrustment Process: Insights from the AAMC CoreEPA PilotMedical Science Educator, 2020
- What Do Program Directors Look for in an Applicant?The Journal of Emergency Medicine, 2019
- Going Beyond the Numerical Scoresheet: Identifying Maladaptive Narcissistic Traits in Residency ApplicantsJournal of Surgical Education, 2019
- Simulation-Based Selection of Surgical Trainees: Considerations, Challenges, and OpportunitiesJournal of the American College of Surgeons, 2016